PS5 Pro Review - Powerful On Paper, Ordinary In Action

As someone who has spent countless hours immersed in the gaming world, I must say that my initial impression of the PS5 Pro is rather underwhelming. Coming from a background where every new console generation brought about revolutionary changes and significant improvements, this one seems to be more of an evolution than a revolution.


When the PlayStation 5 was launched in November 2020, Sony offered a strong argument for purchasing it. Beyond just being a brand new gaming console, its value lay primarily in the games offered at release. The game collection spanned numerous third-party options but more significantly, featured several first-party games that showcased the impressive capabilities of the freshly released PS5.

2024 finds playing Spider-Man: Miles Morales on the original PlayStation 5 as visually stunning, to put it mildly. Navigating Miles Morales through a sprawling, colorful urban landscape, where he gracefully leaps and dives before soaring back into the sky, weaving between towering structures, is nothing short of exhilarating. When it first came out, it was truly spectacular, particularly with its lightning-fast loading times that stood out significantly.

In my opinion, Bluepoint Games’ remake of Demon’s Souls is still the most visually stunning game available on the PlayStation 5. The way they’ve utilized lighting and artistic direction perfectly encapsulates the eerie tension and atmospheric environment that made the original game so beloved. It’s a clear demonstration of Bluepoint’s dedication to quality, as it continues to impress us four years after its release. This just goes to show that even today, the PlayStation 5 and its games can still leave us in awe.

These experiences strongly confirmed that the PS5 was indeed a valuable purchase and hinted at an enticing future for gaming on this platform. The games, along with a couple of others, left no room for doubt – they demonstrated convincingly that Sony’s console marked a significant advancement in gaming generations, making it a leap worth taking.

The PlayStation 5 Pro, which is the second version of the gaming console, aims to find a spot in both new users’ homes and existing PS5 owners’. However, this mid-cycle update caters more to a specific audience. For either group to upgrade, the PS5 Pro must meet the same value justification as the initial console, but it faces a greater challenge due to its higher price point and fewer exclusive games compared to the original PS5.

The PS5 Pro is a more powerful piece of hardware that, physically, looks largely the same as already available models. And so, like most iterative tech with a steep asking price, it needs to communicate its advantages clearly and compellingly. Though it is capable of technically improving gaming experiences, without brand-new games to shine a spotlight on the advantages of having one, the PS5 Pro’s tangible benefits are much harder to grasp for the average person and may even not be enough of a differential to get its target demographic to part with their cash.

In order to ensure openness, this review is written from a unique standpoint – I possess all variations of the PlayStation 5, along with a high-performance gaming PC, Xbox Series X and Series S. While I fit the profile for the Pro model, I am an ordinary individual with a moderate grasp of the hardware’s technical aspects. If you seek detailed frame data or in-depth analysis of AI-powered resolution enhancement, the Digital Foundry team is your go-to source. Instead, I will focus on a common-sense approach to address the question at hand: Is the PS5 Pro a worthwhile purchase for an average gamer looking to buy or upgrade? The answer, as you might guess, is not straightforward.

PS5 Pro Review - Powerful On Paper, Ordinary In Action

Familiar Design

To begin with, let’s discuss the minor alterations in the design of the PS5 Pro: its appearance and dimensions. Unlike the standard PS5, the PS5 Pro is a digital-only console as it lacks a disc drive. In terms of size, it has a more compact design similar to the PS5 Slim rather than the larger original version, although it still requires approximately the same amount of space due to its stand (the launch PS5’s stand is not compatible with the Pro). While the PS5 Slim boasts a glossy exterior finish (except when a disc drive is attached, which provides a matte finish), the Pro retains the matte finish found on the original launch model. Additionally, it stands slightly taller than its predecessors. In summary, the Pro offers a more streamlined and sleek appearance.

The main visual modifications are the vent stripes running along both sides of the console. These stripes serve a practical purpose by enhancing ventilation and cooling, particularly since the Pro model boasts a more potent graphics processing unit that requires extra effort to produce high-quality 4K graphics. Additionally, they add an appealing aesthetic touch, much like adding racing stripes to any car instantly makes it seem cooler. I’ve always admired the design of the PS5, from the Seto Kaiba-inspired flared collars of the original model to the sleek look of the Slim version. The Pro model retains these original design elements and maintains a slimmer profile, making it faster not only due to the racing stripes but also thanks to its improved internal components.

In summary, as was noted earlier, this model doesn’t come with a disc drive, which could be problematic for those who have amassed a collection of physical games or movies and want to use them. At $700, the Pro is quite pricey, and while digital delivery is becoming more prevalent, many consumers still value the ability to insert a game disc into their console. This feature is particularly important for avid PlayStation users who likely have a substantial library of physical PS4 games. The absence of a disc drive in this high-priced model might not be a deal breaker for some, but it does mean that certain essential functions of a video game console are missing. This could put dedicated PlayStation fans in a tricky situation where they either abandon their physical media or pay extra to maintain compatibility. Also, you’ll need to spend more if you don’t already own a vertical stand from the PS5 Slim.

The PS5 Pro may lack certain fundamental features, but it has introduced several striking advancements. At its unveiling, Mark Cerny, who is usually more technical, kept his presentation straightforward and comprehensible. He explained that the Pro allows players to enjoy their games with both the smoother performance of Performance modes and the high-quality graphics of Fidelity mode. This dual functionality is made possible by three key upgrades exclusive to the PS5 Pro.

A Difference In Games?

Initially, I navigated to Demon’s Souls, now enhanced with a PS5 Pro setting within its visual preferences. Herein lies the enticing blend of the heightened frame rate from the performance mode and the detailed cinematics of the Cinematic mode. In the standard Cinematic setting, you’ll notice a slight lag in character movement and jerky camera transitions, yet there’s an undeniable enhancement in visual quality, showcasing crisper details and more pronounced environmental effects. For instance, the mist drifting over the bridge near the Boletarian Palace and the blazing torches appear significantly sharper. Conversely, the Performance mode minimizes several of these effects, offering a much smoother gameplay experience instead.

In the Performance mode of PS5’s Pro edition, Demon’s Souls offers an enhanced gaming experience, showcasing a level of detail that surpasses both Cinematic and Performance modes noticeably. Previously, while playing in both Performance and Cinematic modes, I failed to appreciate the intricate details like the abundance of debris in the air during the tutorial section or the realistic pulsing of light from a lamp’s flame on stone walls. These subtle effects are significantly diminished compared to when using the PS5 Pro option.

As a dedicated fan, I’ve found myself in a unique situation with the latest visual enhancements in Demon’s Souls for PS5 Pro. The subtlety of these changes has led me on a quest to compare modes extensively – cinematic, performance, and PS5 Pro. Spending hours toggling between them was necessary to catch the differences that would otherwise go unnoticed, like a hidden gem on the screen.

The updated version of Alan Wake 2 now takes advantage of the PS5 Pro’s advanced ray-tracing technology, making the game’s atmosphere more immersive. If you opt for the “Quality” setting, the game will look its best only on powerful PCs due to the superior ray tracing it offers, but at a lower frame rate of 30fps. On the other hand, the PS5 Pro strikes a balance in the performance mode, providing a visual quality similar to the Quality mode on a standard PS5, while maintaining a higher frame rate and resolution, resulting in a better overall gaming experience. However, keep in mind that the Performance mode runs at a faster 60fps, which may not be ideal for the entire gameplay experience as suggested by Remedy Entertainment’s Mark Cerny.

As a gamer diving into Marvel’s Spider-Man 2, I appreciate that they haven’t just handed me a few predefined play modes. Instead, they’ve given me the freedom to customize visual effects and features according to my preference, similar to how PC games let you fine-tune settings for optimal performance and aesthetics. This flexibility is thanks to the Fidelity Pro mode, which strikes a balance between 30fps, ray tracing, and adjustable settings for light, shadows, reflections, interiors, ambient occlusion, and more. Additionally, it offers an uncapped frame rate that syncs with variable refresh rate support if your monitor has it. If you’ve got a display capable of 120hz, there’s an option to boost the frame rate, making Spidey’s exploits even smoother. With all options maxed out, Marvel’s Spider-Man 2 is nothing short of breathtaking. At night, you can make out individual lit rooms on skyscrapers from a distance, and changing the time of day, especially witnessing the city bathed in sunrise light, is absolutely mesmerizing.

Among all the games I tried out, the difference between playing with all settings maxed and the less-intensive performance mode was barely perceptible – both modes looked stunning and played smoothly. Similarly, the visual gap between Fidelity Pro and Performance Pro wasn’t obvious unless you compared them directly – they both use ray tracing. Switching between these modes causes the game to reload and restart at a checkpoint, making it challenging to spot differences on a single screen. However, I was amazed that the PS5 Pro allowed me to play at 60 frames per second without sacrificing image quality or missing out on ray tracing and reflections through the performance mode. I preferred this option over the 30fps/VRR/120hz choices offered in Fidelity mode. Thanks to PSSR, Performance Pro’s visuals are similar to playing the game on previous PS5 models in Fidelity Mode, so you’re essentially getting a light version of ray tracing. This disparity is only noticeable if you closely examine reflections or how light interacts with windows. In a fast-paced city-exploring game, how often are you really going to scrutinize these details?

In the game Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth, the PS5 Pro’s introduction significantly improved performance, particularly for those who preferred graphics over smooth gameplay in earlier versions. The new Versatility mode now provides a stunning 4K resolution while maintaining a consistent 60 frames per second (fps) and preserving high-quality graphical details. A dedicated “Graphics” setting allows the game to prioritize visuals even more, though this may cause some fluctuation in fps. Additionally, there are Sharp and Soft options that adjust graphic clarity while still keeping a steady 60fps. Overall, Versatility mode is recommended for playing Rebirth as it addresses the resolution issues seen on the standard PS5.

As a gaming enthusiast, I found myself captivated by Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart’s performance and fidelity modes, reminiscent of Spider-Man 2’s settings. Performance mode, in essence, elevates the visual prowess of the fidelity setting on a standard PS5 with enhanced ray tracing, smooth 60FPS gameplay, and superior image sharpness through PSSR. On the other hand, Fidelity Pro runs at 30FPS, offering adjustable ray tracing, VRR, and options for 120hz.

To Buy Or Not To Buy?

In my experience, I’ve noticed a consistent pattern across various games I’ve played: The PS5 Pro offers similar gameplay experiences, albeit with a choice between two primary modes. One lets you savor the game’s stunning visuals at a lower frame rate, while the other prioritizes smooth performance at higher frame rates. This decision echoes the one we make when playing on the standard PS5. However, even though there are new choices available, that tiny voice in my gaming heart, whispering about the ‘inferior’ experience I was hoping to escape, remains unquieted.

PSSR and its ability to upscale and clean up images also applies to PlayStation 4 games. According to Sony, Game Boost will stabilize or improve the performance of around 8,500 backward-compatible PS4 games. There will also be enhanced image quality for some PS4 games. I decided to put this to the test for a couple of PS4 games. Like with the PS5 titles, I just used my naked eye, but this time I was able to more directly compare the games by connecting an additional PS5 console and using my European account to run the same game on both devices. Then, I could flip between them to see what, if anything, changed.

I assessed the PS4 versions of Bloodborne, Ghost of Tsushima, and Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain. In all three games, I noticed minor enhancements in graphic quality that were more pronounced after prolonged viewing. These improvements are likely due to a reduction in picture blur, making them seem slightly sharper. However, the visual changes are so subtle that many individuals might overlook them.

In essence, the PS5 Pro isn’t a game-changer in terms of how people typically play or enjoy games. The games tested reveal negligible differences that don’t warrant recommending it over the existing, less expensive PS5 models. Unfortunately, high-profile titles like Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth, which are said to benefit more from the Pro, haven’t received necessary updates yet.

That ostensibly makes the PS5 Pro fit neatly into the same category of inessential, premium-priced hardware iteration that Apple’s Pro iPhones occupy. The new tech specs seem exciting, but once you’ve spent the money and have your hands on it, the impact is minimal, leaving you to think about whether your money was better spent elsewhere. The die-hard, need-to-be-on-the-bleeding-edge people will likely see some benefit, but for most people, the differences aren’t essential. And if you’re looking to play games in the best way possible, a PC still presents more value for money.

Mark Cerny and Sony’s team unveiled plans for the PS5 Pro that have been partially realized. The distinction between visual fidelity mode and performance mode is reduced, making the gaming experience more seamless. Features like PSSR and machine-learning chips in consoles are indeed impressive. However, these advancements are currently just promising on paper; they don’t necessarily outweigh the cost-effective alternatives available. In essence, the decision still lies between prioritizing better visuals or performance, but with a less conspicuous compromise. I look forward to the day when the PS5 Pro truly demonstrates its potential to enhance gaming experiences, but for now, it’s a choice for those who can afford it and prefer having the latest console version. For everyone else, a regular PS5 should suffice.

Read More

2024-11-06 14:09