‘The Unseen Sister’ Review: Beijing-Set Tale of Sisters Separated for 17 Years Comes Home Strongly After a Slowish Start

As a seasoned movie buff with a penchant for films that delve deep into human stories, I must say that “The Unseen Sister” is a captivating tale that resonates deeply. Having spent a significant portion of my life traversing the rich and diverse landscapes of Asia, I can appreciate the authenticity that Midi Z brings to his work, particularly in this film set on the China-Myanmar border.


The pivotal instance that shaped drastically distinct lives, wealth, and identities of two sisters from the Yunnan region bordering China and Myanmar is central to “The Unseen Sister,” a blend of crime thriller and family drama. This film, initially based on parts of Zhang Yueran’s 2017 novella titled “Sister,” represents the most commercially oriented work by prominent Taiwanese director Midi Z (known for “Nina Wu” and “Road to Mandalay”). After its successful domestic debut on October 26, “Sister” made its international premiere in competition at the Tokyo Film Festival.

In the same vein as many of Midi Z’s productions, his latest movie delves into facets of his personal history. Born Chinese in Myanmar, Midi Z relocated to Taiwan during his teenage years and adopted Taiwanese citizenship. Notably, some of the credits at the end show him as “Midi Z, (Taiwan, China).” While the majority of the film “Sister” unfolds in Beijing, the emotional core of the narrative lies in Yunnan province, a region bordering Myanmar that has historically been a hub for human trafficking and illegal activities.

The heart of the movie revolves around the exact events that transpired seventeen years ago in Yunnan, where Qioa Yan (Zhao Liying) was forcibly separated from her older, unnamed sister (Xin Zhilei) and relocated to Beijing. Since then, Yan has risen to become a well-known yet troubled film star, expressing that she appears worn in real life but polished on screen. Tired of everything and seeking to end her longstanding professional relationship with manager and potential lover Shen (Huang Jue), Yan has succumbed to his persuasion and taken on a role eerily reminiscent of her past. Unfortunately, Yan’s sister, referred to only as “Da” in the credits (meaning “big”), is struggling under the burden of an abusive husband Liang (Dong Baoshi), a compulsive gambler who owes a significant debt to a ruthless local gang. The message Sister receives from Liang’s creditors is a grim one: “Pay up or face death.

A significant piece of the puzzle falls into place when Sister unexpectedly appears in Beijing, coinciding with Yan receiving ominous messages reading “I know your secret.” However, this encounter is far from joyful, as Sister’s words reveal. Upon surveying Yan’s luxurious apartment, she coldly remarks, “You took everything from me.” Specifically, 17 years prior, Sister had given up her ID card to Yan, whose birth was clandestine and unregistered due to China’s one-child policy, fearing economic sanctions and job loss. Although the screenplay doesn’t explicitly say so, it is evident that Yan was an unwanted second child at that time. By being given Yan’s identity and secretly relocated to Beijing, Sister was left stranded without a legitimate identity, thus unable to climb the social ladder in society.

Although these disclosures are captivating, they don’t immediately create the electrifying intensity that one might anticipate. The film’s initial portion primarily focuses on Liang’s extortion schemes and kidnappings, which lack the nail-biting tension and suspense that such high-stakes situations should convey. The looming risk of Yan’s true identity being exposed, which could potentially end their career, is clearly set up, but it fails to generate the level of tension and suspense that such a dramatic secret typically warrants.

In simpler terms, “Sister” becomes more impactful as the title characters confront their tumultuous past, one they had no say in, which has led them to live lives under the thumb of manipulative men. Similar to Midi Z’s earlier work, “Nina Wu,” Yan decides she won’t be pushed around by Shen (a deceptively calm and charming figure representing insidious coercion). She refuses to be used as a pawn in his scheme to make money on the stock market. The story gains depth when Yan recognizes that Liang doesn’t deserve her unquestioning loyalty, and the arrival of her child raises intriguing questions about the baby’s identity and future. This leads to a gripping sequence of events that ultimately changes their lives.

Midi-Z’s extensive experience in docudramas (“City of Jade,” “The Road to Mandalay” and “The Clinic”) is clearly evident throughout these passages, particularly during a lengthy flashback to Yunnan which provides additional insight into the tragic circumstances surrounding Yan adopting her sister’s identity. While the crime thriller aspects are adequate, there is a palpable sense of intensity, immediacy, and authenticity when the story centers around Yan and Sister as they bravely and at times dangerously fight for their right to self-determination. It is during these scenes that the lead actors Zhou and Xin truly excel, effectively portraying the internal struggles between fear and unyielding determination that drive their characters.

In a simple, understated manner, Director of Photography Florian J.E. Zinke captures the scenes, which are further enhanced by Lim Giong’s soft strings music. The movie, titled “Sister,” uses color-coded subtitles to represent different languages; Mandarin is shown in white, while Yunnan dialect appears yellow. This inventive technique enhances the drama, as the language choice at certain moments sheds light on characters’ traits and motivations that might have remained hidden otherwise. Although it’s a work of fiction, the film ends with factual information about the crimes committed and sentences served by the main characters.

Read More

2024-10-30 22:47