Woman of the Hour: How was Rodney Alcala caught in real life?

As a seasoned crime enthusiast who has followed countless stories of serial killers, I must say that the tale of Rodney Alcala, also known as The Dating Game Killer, is one that truly stands out. The Netflix movie, Woman of the Hour, does a commendable job of shedding light on this chilling story, but it’s important to remember that real life often presents a more complex and intricate narrative than what can be portrayed in a film.


The series ‘Netflix’s Woman of the Hour’ delves into the chilling tale of the Dating Game Killer, Rodney Alcala, focusing on his notorious television performance. However, the true story of how Alcala was apprehended is actually much more intricate in reality.

In the year 1978, notorious killer Rodney Alcala found his way onto television screens. He disguised himself as a contestant on the popular dating show The Dating Game. Later, it was revealed that he had committed numerous crimes, which earned him the chilling moniker ‘The Dating Game Murderer’.

In this new Netflix flick, Woman of the Hour, I found myself captivated by the narrative. Scattered within his TV stint were glimpses of Alcala’s atrocious actions – the very deeds that ultimately led to his apprehension.

But the reality isn’t as simple, and Alcala continued his spree long after his initial arrests. Here’s how Rodney Alcala was caught, as well as the details of his conviction.

Rodney Alcala’s arrest

In July 1979, Rodney Alcala was ultimately apprehended when his parole officer identified him from a law enforcement drawing.

As a true crime enthusiast, I can’t help but reflect on the chilling case of Robin Samsoe, a 12-year-old girl whose life was tragically taken. Back then, I lived in Huntington Beach, California, where this young ballet student was last seen riding her bike to class. The man who took her life was none other than Rodney Alcala, a predator who ambushed his victim. After capturing Robin, he subjected her to unimaginable horrors – beating, raping, and ultimately stabbing her to death. Her lifeless body was found in the Los Angeles foothills, a grim reminder of the evil that lurks among us.

Eventually, the authorities discovered her lifeless body along Santa Anita Canyon Road. After Samsoe’s companions managed to recall Alcala’s distinctive features, the police released a composite sketch based on this description, as Alcala had previously approached them on the beach and asked to take their photograph.

Woman of the Hour: How was Rodney Alcala caught in real life?

At that point, Alcala’s parole office linked him to the sketch and alerted the authorities. Subsequently, they conducted a search at his mother’s residence and uncovered a bill for a storage unit in Seattle.

During a search inside the locker, the earrings matching DNA from a previous victim, Charlotte Lamb, were discovered.

In July 1979, Alcala was apprehended and detained without bond. His initial conviction was for the killing of Samsoe, earning him a death sentence.

Over the course of several retrials, additional murder charges were brought against him, eventually leading to a conviction for seven murders. Despite being sentenced to death, Alcala passed away in prison due to natural causes at the age of 77, without specification of the exact cause of his demise.

It wasn’t the first time he’d been apprehended

Prior to his incarceration, Alcala had been apprehended on three separate occasions – in 1971, 1974, and 1979. Each time, he was set free afterwards.

In 1968, Alcala was initially apprehended following an incident where he abducted and attacked Tali Shaprio on her journey to school. A bystander’s testimony had guided the police to his apartment, where they discovered Tali, who was still conscious but slipped into a coma for 32 days afterward.

Instead of California, Alcala found refuge in New York City, where he is known to have perpetrated another crime – the murder of Cornelia Crilley, a 23-year-old air hostess for Trans World Airlines.

Woman of the Hour: How was Rodney Alcala caught in real life?

In 1971, Alcala was included on the FBI’s List of Ten Most Wanted Fugitives. Eventually, he was apprehended due to his photograph being recognized by two kids attending an arts camp at a local post office.

1) Shapiro’s parents objected to her testifying during the trial, and Alcala received a three-year sentence for molesting a child. However, after spending nearly sixteen months behind bars, he was granted parole in 1974.

Two months later, he was once more taken into custody for assaulting a 13-year-old girl and returned to prison. In 1976, following a two-year sentence, he was freed from prison again.

A little over a year following his stint on The Dating Game, in February 1979, Rodney Alcala was apprehended once more. He had picked up Monique Hoyt, a 15-year-old girl he met while hitchhiking in California, under the guise of photographing her.

Upon reaching a remote mountainous spot near Banning, he suddenly attacked her. Later, Alcala brutally assaulted and raped Hoyt, followed by striking her in the head with a rock. For some unexplained reason, Alcala subsequently drove her back down the mountain, providing an opportunity for Hoyt to flee when he made a pit stop at a gas station to relieve himself.

This is the same story chosen to end Woman of the Hour, with a young hitchhiker escaping Alcala using her intelligence and opportunity to talk him down. In the movie, his arrest happens almost instantaneously at the gas station.

Today, Hoyt made a call to the authorities, leading to Alcala’s capture once more. However, not long after, his mother managed to secure his release on bail. Following his freedom, he went on to commit two more murders – Jill Parenteau in Burbank and Robin Samsoe in Huntington Beach – before his ultimate arrest in 1979.

Read More

2024-10-20 13:18