10 Best horror games that aren’t too scary

As someone who has been through their fair share of horror games and movies, I can confidently say that these five games are perfect for those who enjoy the spooky season but aren’t big fans of being scared out of their wits!


Not all horror games are made for the bravest souls or those who thrive on jump scares. If you’re more into the spooky atmosphere and prefer a game that leans towards eerie rather than terrifying, you’re in the right place. Below are ten of the best horror games that aren’t too scary. All of these games have a unique take on what horror is, giving you the spookiness you seek without keeping you up at night.

Top 10 Horror Games That Won’t Scare You

These ten games share characteristics that make them suitable for being labeled as either comfortably eerie or mildly scary. While they may contain elements reminiscent of horror, their intensity is significantly less than what one would find in contemporary horror games, which are often characterized by blood, gore, and extreme grotesqueness. Unfortunately, there isn’t a specific genre for these “spooky” games, as they don’t fit cleanly into the horror category.

10 Best horror games that aren’t too scary

Similar to Cult of the Lamb that stands out among my article about horror games based on cult themes due to its adorable aesthetic, these ten games subtly explore the theme of horror rather than making it the central focus throughout the gameplay. Here’s a list, starting with the scariest and gradually moving towards the least terrifying!

10. OXENFREE

10 Best horror games that aren’t too scary

This one might seem too scary or spooky on the surface, but stick with me. OXENFREE is a supernatural game about a group of teens who accidentally open a ghostly rift on an abandoned military island. The spooky vibes are there, but the game is an immersive, interactive mystery, where your choices shape the story.

In a style more focused on storytelling than jump scares, this game is ideal for those who appreciate chilling narratives. You’ll find yourself deeply engrossed in the story and characters, so beware as you might forget about the danger lurking nearby. The unsettling ambiance of OXENFREE is agreed upon by many on Reddit.

9. Night in the Woods

10 Best horror games that aren’t too scary

Night in the Woods delivers a richer, more emotionally profound journey. Though it contains some spooky instances, the game primarily explores the haunting realities of existence.

In this game, you take on the role of Mae, a woman who leaves college and goes back to her humble town, only to discover it’s not the same place she left. The authentic characters, everyday challenges, and the enigmatic vibe of the town make the experience feel tangible. Players can easily relate to these characters, which enhances immersion. Despite its melancholic tone, the game’s mystery is compelling enough to draw you in – and by the end, you might find yourself becoming emotionally invested in these characters.

8. Pumpkin Jack

10 Best horror games that aren’t too scary

If you enjoy playing platform games that offer a darker edge, Pumpkin Jack certainly delivers! You’ll find yourself in control of the main character, Pumpkin Jack, as he fights his way through colorful yet eerie settings brimming with puzzles and fast-paced action. The graphics possess a unique cartoonish style, while the storyline presents an evil ally to aid, all wrapped up in a lighthearted and amusing atmosphere.

The obstacles lie primarily within the domain of physics riddles and jumping challenges, thus allowing you to appreciate the eerie ambiance without experiencing actual fright. Ideal for those seeking a Halloween atmosphere devoid of terror.

7. Lost in Random

10 Best horror games that aren’t too scary

In the game “Lost in Random,” there’s an unusual ambiance reminiscent of a Tim Burton movie. Here, your journey unfolds in a bizarre land, and the outcome of events is dictated by the cast of a die.

Although the atmosphere is undeniably mysterious and ominous, the game’s emphasis on action and exploration ensures it steers clear of being truly frightening. Its enchantingly gothic style transforms it into a whimsical journey rather than something that might cause alarm. Imagine it as a blend of eerie and adorable – a realm shrouded in darkness, indeed, yet not overly distressing.

6. Don’t Starve

10 Best horror games that aren’t too scary

In Don’t Starve, the sketchy, one-of-a-kind creatures and art design lend it a charming, fantastical atmosphere, but it also has a haunting, ominous undertone. The game places you in a wilderness, forcing you to survive by crafting tools, foraging resources, and exploring on your own.

In this game, even though its environment might be harsh, the humor and unique art style ensure that the experience remains lighter rather than overly intense. You’ll find yourself laughing just as much as you’re concerned about staying alive. The absence of jump scares or truly frightening moments means that it’s more about an amusing survival challenge than a traditional horror game.

5. MediEvil

10 Best horror games that aren’t too scary

As a fan who craves an adrenaline rush with a touch of the supernatural, I highly recommend giving MediEvil a try. This hack-and-slash gem offers a thrilling adventure that’s decidedly eerie, albeit filled with themes like death, monsters, and resurrection. Despite its dark undertones, it’s the humorous return of Sir Daniel Fortesque from the dead, battling through spectral landscapes to save his kingdom, that makes it truly stand out. The 2019 remake breathes new life into this timeless classic, making it a must-play for any adventurer looking for a spine-tingling experience!

In this game, you’ll encounter bone-chilling skeletons, spine-tingling ghouls, and unsettling surroundings, but don’t be scared – there’s more laughter than fright here! If you remember playing the original version a few decades back like I do, get ready for a flood of nostalgia.

4. Hollow Knight

10 Best horror games that aren’t too scary

Although it has a gloomy appearance, the game Hollow Knight offers action-filled adventures within the Metroidvania genre, making it feel thrilling rather than frightening.

You’ll delve into a strange subterranean realm teeming with bizarre insect-like creatures, uncover hidden truths, and engage formidable adversaries. Although the environment carries a touch of spookiness, and some of the opponents might seem unsettling, the emphasis lies on discovery, combat, and narrative development. The experience is thrilling rather than terrifying – an engaging world to traverse, brimming with puzzles and allure.

3. Luigi’s Mansion 3

10 Best horror games that aren’t too scary

Isn’t it thought that horror lacks charm? On the contrary, Luigi’s Mansion 3 offers an enchanting take on the genre, placing you in the shoes of Luigi as he chases ghosts through a spooky hotel. However, this game isn’t about heart-stopping terror; it’s a delightful journey filled with humor and puzzles, where Luigi uses his ghost-vacuum to navigate the environment and save his friends. The only thing that could potentially give you a fright is just how endearing the ghosts are!

The game offers an abundance of appeal through its wit, enchantment, and brain-teasing puzzles, making it ideal for those seeking a spooky experience without the real-life shivers.

2. Costume Quest 1 & 2

10 Best horror games that aren’t too scary

In this deal, you get two games for the price of one, as both are worth your while, especially if you appreciate Halloween without the usual frightening elements. In Costume Quest, you explore a neighborhood with companions, collecting candy and fighting sweet-toothed monsters in costumes that turn you into mighty champions. The atmosphere is eerie yet endearing, brimming with Double Fine’s signature wit and humor.

In my enthusiastic take, I’d say: Jumping right back into Costume Quest 2 feels like continuing an adventure with old friends! It builds upon the original game by introducing handy features such as maps and collectible cards that enrich the combat experience. While there are some fights along the way, it’s mostly a fun-filled journey where you’ll find yourself chuckling more than cowering in terror.

1. Graveyard Keeper

10 Best horror games that aren’t too scary

Ultimately, we reach Graveyard Keeper, the game that takes home the title for the least frightening horror-like game in our selection. This game is more about overseeing a whimsical, medieval graveyard instead.

As a fan, I must say that despite the game revolving around managing corpses, its playful humor and captivating art style transform what might seem a somber subject into an enjoyable and delightful experience. Instead of being terrorized by ghosts or monsters, you’ll find yourself focusing on efficiently operating your cemetery. It turns out that overseeing a graveyard can be surprisingly comforting!

We have upgraded our commenting platform! Existing comments will be imported over the next few weeks.

Read More

2024-10-06 03:51