Thunder’s NBA 2K25 ratings that are 100% wrong

As a seasoned gamer with over two decades under my belt, I must say that the NBA 2K franchise has always had its quirks when it comes to player ratings. However, this year’s version seems to have hit a new low (or high, depending on how you look at it). The Oklahoma City Thunder roster is a gamer’s dream, yet the ratings are a bit of a nightmare.


For an NBA 2K25 enthusiast, the Oklahoma City Thunder’s lineup is a fantasy come true. The team boasts talent from every level, ranging from stars like Shai Gilgeous-Alexander to rising stars such as Chet Holmgren and Jalen Williams. They also have versatile players like Lu Dort and Alex Caruso, along with emerging young talents in Cason Wallace and Dillon Jones. With so many talented players on the roster, there isn’t a single player you wouldn’t want to team up with in the latest basketball video game that’s now open for public play.

Whenever a fresh 2K edition rolls out, numerous gamers find themselves underrated in terms of ratings. Conversely, some players are unjustifiably overrated within the game. Given that our squad boasts an impressive future and championship potential, many will prefer to play with the Thunder in this iteration of 2K. As a result, we decided to scrutinize their roster and identify any rating discrepancies introduced by the 2K team.

Thunder’s Ajay Mitchell (68) is rated too low

In the 2024 NBA Draft, Ajay Mitchell was chosen as the 38th overall pick by the Thunder. This means that he was one of just three players that the team drafted and brought into a roster that’s already brimming with talent. Furthermore, Mitchell is only under a two-way contract, which typically limits players to a lower rating in the 60s. However, Mitchell was considered an exceptional value for his selection, making him an exception to this rule.

The UC Santa Barbara product was arguably the best second-rounder selected, and he perfectly fits the Thunder’s system. Additionally, he was one of the standout performers at the NBA Summer League. Before being shut down after showing enough at Summer League, Mitchell had a stat line of 16.4 points, 4.6 assists, and 3.0 rebounds per game.

Mitchell is exceptionally adaptable on the court, and with Nikola Topic, another draftee from Thunder, being out for the season, he potentially could find a spot in Oklahoma City’s talented player pool immediately. Among this year’s second-round picks, only four had a rating of 70 or higher, but Mitchell was worthy of being included among them.

Isaiah Hartenstein (81) shouldn’t be rated as one of Thunder’s five best players

Thunder’s NBA 2K25 ratings that are 100% wrong

We strongly endorsed the OKC Thunder acquiring Isaiah Hartenstein during free agency. With sufficient financial resources and a requirement for additional size and rebounding, Hartenstein seemed like an ideal match given his previous experience with the New York Knicks. Consequently, Oklahoma City made a substantial investment to secure his services from the open market. Now, the Thunder boast one of the top backup centers in the league, providing valuable relief for Chet Holmgren.

In a simplified rephrase: Hartenstein offers a strong interior presence and displays remarkable passing skills for his center role. However, he’s only started 61 out of 322 career games, which suggests he may serve as a long-term backup in Oklahoma City. Interestingly, NBA 2K25 ranks him the fifth best player on the Thunder roster with an overall rating of 81.

Moving his rating closer to 80 seems plausible but may not be essential given his significant impact on the Knicks’ late-season and postseason run last year. However, there are teammates from the Thunder who deserve a higher rating than him. For instance, Luo Dort currently has a 2K rating of just 80.

One of the top-tier, arguably the best, perimeter defenders in the league, Dort has proven himself. He’s significantly enhanced his offensive game, particularly with his ability to accurately hit long-range shots. For years, Dort has been a starter for the Thunder, and his pairing with Alex Caruso will create an outstanding defensive duo, boosting his abilities even more. Hartenstein was a valuable free agent pickup by the Thunder, but it’s premature to rank him higher than Dort.

Isaiah Joe deserves a better 3-point rating than the 85 he received

Thunder’s NBA 2K25 ratings that are 100% wrong

Hey there, fellow gaming enthusiast! As a sharpshooter myself in NBA 2K25, I’ve got to express my thoughts on Isaiah Joe. His overall rating of 78 seems about right, but there’s a hitch when it comes to his three-point rating – it’s set at 85. Now, let me tell you, Joe is one of the best marksmen in the real NBA, not just in this game!

It’s safe to say that if you were to ask any member of the Thunder team, staff, or fan base about their best three-point shooter, they would likely point to Isaiah Joe. In fact, we believe his three-point shooting percentage is well over 90%. Two years ago, Joe made 40.9% of his shots from beyond the arc on an average of 5.4 attempts per game, and last year he made 41.6% of his long-range shots on 4.5 attempts per game.

In a team brimming with excellent long-range passers who consistently break through the defense, Joe frequently receives passes for shots from far away, and he makes these opportunities count at an exceptionally high rate. Labeling him with a three-point rating of 85 is not just inaccurate but downright disrespectful to his abilities.

Read More

2024-09-18 19:09