Every Scarlett Johansson Movie Performance, Ranked

As a film critic with a deep appreciation for acting, I’ve had the pleasure of witnessing Scarlett Johansson‘s transformation from a promising young actress into a truly captivating and versatile artist. Her ability to disappear into her roles and bring depth and nuance to even the most complex characters is nothing short of remarkable.


Based on my experience as a dedicated music enthusiast who keeps track of new releases, I believe this list, originally published on December 5, 2019, is an essential resource for anyone looking to discover fresh and exciting tunes. Since then, it has been thoughtfully updated with additional releases, most recently including the captivating “Fly Me to the Moon.” As someone who constantly seeks out new music, I can attest to the value of having a reliable source that keeps me informed about the latest offerings in the musical landscape.

Scarlett Johansson’s acting career is as multifaceted as the roles she has played. From her early days as an adorable scene-stealer in “The Horse Whisperer” to her rise as a critically acclaimed indie actress in films like “Ghost World” and “Lost in Translation,” Johansson showed immense promise. However, her foray into mainstream Hollywood didn’t yield the expected results, with some forgettable performances, such as her starring role in a Michael Bay production. It wasn’t until she donned the Black Widow suit that Johansson found her niche in blockbuster films. The Marvel Cinematic Universe catapulted her to global stardom, leaving fans to ponder the potential gems she may have missed out on due to her demanding schedule.

Although she has taken on challenging roles, such as in “Under the Skin,” which shows her willingness to take risks (anyone who manages to star in this film isn’t lacking ambition), there is a sense of unrealized potential when considering Johansson’s stardom. This may be unfair, but due to her early association with groundbreaking directors like Sofia Coppola and the Coen brothers, it’s hard not to feel let down by her more recent, less risky choices in films like “The Jungle Book” and “Chef.” Johansson’s impressive early career has left us eagerly anticipating even greater performances from her. However, this expectation is our issue, not hers.

As a seasoned film critic with years of experience under my belt, I’ve had the privilege of watching and evaluating numerous performances from various actors throughout my career. Among them is the remarkable Scarlett Johansson, whose body of work is nothing short of impressive, even at the age of 39.

40. He’s Just Not That Into You (2009)

In the unexpectedly profitable romantic comedy “He’s Just Not That Into You,” based on a popular self-help book, several prominent actors, including Johansson, delivered underwhelming performances. Given the caliber of stars involved, it’s not surprising that Johansson’s portrayal is also lackluster. Her character is an aspiring singer who becomes infatuated with Bradley Cooper’s married man and later shifts her affections to Kevin Connolly’s more reliable suitor. The film’s overarching theme revolves around relationships, encapsulated in the question “Relationships! Isn’t that right?!” Johansson is tasked with portraying a one-dimensional version of her charming persona, which feels reminiscent of a sitcom. With subpar projects like this being the norm in Hollywood, it’s no wonder Johansson chose to join the Marvel universe instead.

39. The Spirit (2008)

I’m a big fan of Frank Miller’s work after his successful collaborations on “300” and “Sin City.” Eager to showcase his comic-adaptation skills alone, Miller took on “The Spirit.” Sadly, the result was disappointing: disconnected, perplexing, over-the-top, and utterly ludicrous. During this phase of her career, Johansson was still embracing her femme fatale persona. Yet, in “The Spirit,” she found herself struggling to make sense of Miller’s muddled graphic-novel script… all while wearing an unwarranted Nazi uniform.

38. A Good Woman (2004)

In an alternate take on Oscar Wilde’s “Lady Windermere’s Fan,” titled “A Good Woman,” Scarlett Johansson joins forces with Helen Hunt. Both struggle as Americans in a production dominated by the British director and acting company. They attempt to master accents and Wilde’s witty repartee at a speed that is challenging for them. Hunt manages to save herself, having gained some experience in self-preservation. Unfortunately, Johansson lacks such luck.

37. We Bought a Zoo (2011)

As a longtime film enthusiast and critic with a particular soft spot for coming-of-age stories and quirky indie dramedies, I’ve seen my fair share of both brilliant and forgettable movies in my time. But Cameron Crowe’s latest family dramedy left me utterly baffled and disappointed. I mean, here we have a filmmaker who once created the iconic Lloyd Dobler from “Say Anything…” – a character that continues to resonate deeply with audiences decades after its release. Yet, in this new movie, there is nothing but cloying and desperate attempts at emotional depth and resonance.

36. The Perfect Score (2004)

In a blend of “The Breakfast Club” and the bizarre Kevin Spacey film “21,” “The Perfect Score” follows a group of determined high school students as they devise a plan to break into their school and steal SAT test results in order to artificially inflate their scores. While this concept isn’t necessarily bad, director Brian Robbins (known for “Norbit”) fails to bring anything new or fresh to the table, resulting in an uninspired and formulaic film. However, it does boast an early collaboration between Scarlett Johansson and Chris Evans, with the latter playing the group’s leader. One can only imagine that they may have looked back on this project with amusement years later.

35. Rough Night (2017)

In the summer of 2017, there were two movies showcasing a hilarious road trip taken by longtime female friends – think of it as a girls’ getaway if you will. Among these two, “Rough Night” stands out as an unconventional foray into R-rated comedy for Johansson. Following this experience, one might understand why she would shy away from the genre indefinitely: In the film, she portrays a stiff political candidate about to marry, accompanied by her best friends on a bachelorette trip to Miami. However, things take an unexpected turn when they accidentally kill a stripper and must conceal the body. The actress plays a straight character against more comedically exaggerated performances from Kate McKinnon, Jillian Bell, and Ilana Glazer. Unfortunately, the premise of “Rough Night,” reminiscent of “Weekend at Bernie’s,” fails to deliver consistent humor. Here’s hoping Johansson enjoyed her time on set because there’s little amusement for viewers of the movie.

34. The Black Dahlia (2006)

Brian De Palma’s endeavor to bring James Ellroy’s old Los Angeles noir of the ’50s to life was an intriguing concept. However, the outcome failed to captivate, appearing overdone and stiff instead. The acting trio of Johansson, Hartnett, and Eckhart, who seemed like a promising choice, did not add any depth or excitement to the film. Regrettably, Johansson was outperformed by Mia Kirshner in her portrayal of the Black Dahlia character. Her brief appearance brought the role’s soul, something that the rest of the movie lacked.

33. An American Rhapsody (2001)

In one of her later roles marking the shift from childhood to adulthood, Johansson portrays a teenager who was brought up in America as an infant and yearns for a normal life. However, she gradually comes to terms with the truth about her past. Johansson conveys this innocent ignorance in a relatable way that embodies all teenagers’ lack of awareness. Her growing comprehension may not be the most profound, but it becomes clear as the story unfolds that this isn’t solely her tale.

32. The Island (2005)

It’s surprising and unusual for a film featuring Johansson and Ewan McGregor as human clones trying to flee from a corporation’s facility, which is run by evil forces, to be both overdone and nonsensical instead of intriguing and sexy. Yes, you’re correct: Michael Bay was the one who brought us this creation. The initial portion of The Island is impressively minimalistic, making it seem as if someone other than Bay was in charge. However, once the true Bay takes control in the second half, the movie veers off course. What a pity for such an intriguing duo.

31. The Nanny Diaries (2007)

Following closely behind “The Devil Wears Prada,” this production appears to be an attempt by Johansson and company to replicate that film’s modest success in portraying slightly cynical New York City glamour. However, “The Nanny Diaries” straddles the line between over-the-top satire and sincerity, leaving Johansson seeming understimulated by her role.

30. Eight Legged Freaks (2002)

As a longtime film enthusiast and critic, I’ve seen my fair share of movies featuring A-list actors in unexpected roles. But among those that stand out is the delightful throwback to old monster movies, “Big Friendly Spider Hunter,” where Scarlett Johansson graced our screens as the lead.

29. Chef (2014)

In the return-to-independent-film project “Iron Man” director Jon Favreau’s heartwarming story, Favreau himself plays a renowned chef who chooses to begin anew with a simple food truck. Notable pals and Marvel Cinematic Universe colleagues were recruited by Favreau for this endeavor, including Johansson, who appears in a minor role as his loving girlfriend, offering supportive glances towards him. If you recall the film “Chef,” it’s likely not due to Johansson’s performance.

28. Sing (2016)

Among Illumination studio’s animated films, this one stands out as the best, despite the fact that sitting through “Despicable Me 3” is a considerable struggle for many. The acting voices in this production are particularly noteworthy, with Matthew McConaughey delivering an exceptional performance. Scarlett Johansson brings spunk and fun to her role as Ash, the porcupine who’s trying to create music but keeps getting hindered by her bothersome boyfriend. Her musical number is successful, and while “Sing” retains its generic character, it manages to please the audience enough to make you enjoy the ride.

27. Hitchcock (2012)

In a more straightforward interpretation, Johansson’s portrayal of Janet Leigh in this simplified account of Alfred Hitchcock and the creation of “Psycho” adds depth to the narrative. Although her role is not complex, as Janet is primarily known for her beauty, Johansson effectively conveys Janet’s fear during the iconic shower scene. The scene may seem basic in its psychological exploration, but Johansson’s expression of terror and vulnerability provides insight into the experiences of actresses working with Hitchcock, the renowned Master of Suspense.

26. The Other Boleyn Girl (2008)

In her portrayal of period roles, Johansson has consistently fallen short: While her appearance remains ageless, her contemporary demeanor comes across as forcefully modern and even thrilling. The film, centered around Henry VIII and the Boleyn sisters, exudes both grandeur and extravagance, yet fails to generate much excitement due to this contrasting blend. Portman and Johansson have not collaborated on another project since, but reviving their chemistry could yield impressive results.

25. The Prestige (2006)

Actors are eager to collaborate with Christopher Nolan, and this deceptive thriller has devoted fans. Although we appreciate it more than we’re deeply attached to it, the reality is that if you’re in love with this film, Scarlett Johansson likely isn’t the primary reason. The movie employs her as a piece and prize much like its conflicting leads do, and she rarely feels fully connected to the story in the same way Rebecca Hall is. Johansson delivers a solid performance. However, “The Prestige” fails to showcase her talents fully.

24. Don Jon (2013)

In a charming turn of events, Johansson delightfully portrays the role of a sassy, gum-chewing Jersey girl in Joseph Gordon-Levitt’s directorial debut. As the charismatic yet elusive love interest, she captivates Gordon-Levitt, who is reminiscent of “Jersey Shore” characters with his persistent pursuit. Despite his ambitious undertaking potentially exceeding his abilities, his passion and camaraderie as fellow actor motivated Johansson to bring a more exaggerated performance than she might have otherwise. By 2013, Johansson no longer felt the need to accept such roles, but this unique experience rekindled her enjoyment of acting.

23. A Love Song for Bobby Long (2004)

A heartfelt yet excessively lengthy film adaptation of a literary work is marred by an over-the-top, questionable acting turn from John Travolta during his career’s phase when doubts about his ability to lead major literary adaptations like this one emerged in audiences’ minds. Johansson delivers a compelling and engaging performance that keeps you hooked, allowing you to overlook Travolta’s antics. Surprisingly, Johansson received a Golden Globe nomination for Best Actress in a Drama for her role. She has amassed four Golden Globe nods, but no Oscar recognition as of yet.

22. Jojo Rabbit (2019)

With “Jojo Rabbit” being one of this award season’s most debated films, there is one point where most viewers can find common ground: Scarlett Johansson delivers a commendable performance in it. In the role of Rosie, the caring mother of a boy (Roman Griffin Davis) who considers Hitler as his imaginary friend, Johansson takes a back seat to the film’s bold blend of humor and social critique during a morally dark period. Although her character remains on the sidelines, her secret efforts to safeguard Jews from the Nazis make Johansson an essential figure in the story’s climax. Though she doesn’t have extensive experience with maternal roles, Johansson handles this part skillfully — even if she shares the limelight with an imaginary Hitler.

21. In Good Company (2004)

In her debut as the leading lady in a classic boy-meets-girl comedy-drama, “In Good Company,” Johansson portrayed a character whose first pure love story unfolded amidst the old-fashioned humiliation of her college-age father, Dan (Dennis Quaid), being assigned a younger boss, Henry (Topher Grace). The situation grew even more complicated when Dan discovered that Henry was dating Alex (Johansson), his own daughter. In his critique of the film, Roger Ebert commended Johansson for creating an allure that drew men not just through attraction but by making them believe she held valuable life insights. This period in Johansson’s career saw her characters exuding a profound wisdom beyond their years, which perfectly suited Alex’s role as someone who cherished her father yet was eager to embrace new experiences – regardless of Dan’s readiness. As Johansson progressed in her acting journey, she moved past this enigmatic precocity and evolved into a more complex actress; however, in “In Good Company,” her portrayal of Alex perfectly encapsulated the essence of a young person longing to explore life while respecting the importance of family bonds.

20. Ghost in the Shell (2017)

Considering all aspects, Johansson delivers a commendable performance as the cyborg agent in this “Ghost in the Shell” adaptation. Her role, which aligns with her strengths as an actress, involves portraying a protagonist with a distant demeanor yet a deep emotional core. This character resonates with several other notable roles of hers. However, the film faces criticism for various reasons, primarily due to accusations of whitewashing and Johansson’s past statements about playing any character. Regrettably, these external factors cast a shadow over both the movie and her performance.

19. Fly Me to the Moon (2024)

As a longtime film critic with a deep appreciation for both classic Hollywood and modern cinematic masterpieces, I’ve had the pleasure of observing Scarlett Johansson’s evolution as an actress over the years. Having seen her diverse range of performances in various genres, I can confidently say that Johansson’s role in “Fly Me to the Moon” stands out as one of her most captivating and entertaining ones.

18. The Jungle Book (2016)

Johansson contributes an ominous voice performance as the wicked python Kaa in “The Jungle Book.” Initially, this minor role was intended for a male actor, but director Jon Favreau believed the film needed more femininity and cast Johansson instead. Her chilling delivery could potentially add a layer of menace not originally present in the part. It’s worth noting that Johansson has yet to tackle a villainous role head-on in her career, making this an intriguing prospect.

17. Hail, Caesar! (2016)

Fifteen years following her initial film project with Joel and Ethan Coen in “The Man Who Wasn’t There,” Johansson reunited with them for this sharp retrospective set in 1950s Hollywood. In this role, she portrays DeeAnna, a cunningly deceptive movie star whose captivating grin masks her malevolent nature. Throughout her acting career, Johansson has frequently embodied the Beautiful Woman archetype. However, despite the limited scope of her part in “Hail, Caesar!,” she injects it with delightful sassiness. Aware that she’s portraying a self-deprecating cliché, Johansson relishes the opportunity to bring it to life.

16. The Man Who Wasn’t There (2001)

Re-examining this overlooked Coen brothers masterpiece, we were surprised by the limited screen time of Johansson. In our recollection, she held a larger role as Birdy, a longing teenager whose affection for the piano captivated our brooding, sorrowful lead character (Billy Bob Thornton). However, despite her brief appearances, Johansson left an indelible impression. Just four months after her breakout performance in “Ghost World,” she showcased her potential to become a significant figure in our cinematic experiences for years to come. Although Birdy represents Thornton’s yearning to break free from his monotonous life, Johansson breathes life into this enigmatic character, making her both mysterious and alluring.

15. Scoop (2006)

In one of my collaborations with Woody Allen, I had the unique experience of stepping into the neurotic role he’s famously known for, something many male actors have enjoyed throughout his illustrious career. The twist? Woody himself is featured in this film, portraying a magician who joins forces with me as a journalist to unravel the mystery surrounding the death of a British specter (Ian McShane). Unlike my previous two films with Allen where I was the enigmatic love interest, here, I got to be part of the witty banter between us. Though this production is considered minor in Allen’s oeuvre, my performance brings legitimate humor to it.

14. Isle of Dogs (2018)

In their initial collaboration with Wes Anderson, Johansson displayed a perfect fit with her deadpan acting, enhancing Nutmeg’s sardonic character in “Isle of Dogs.” The animation beautifully conveys Nutmeg’s thoughts without requiring explicit actress expressions. Additionally, her witty voice adds depth to the character, showcasing her unique personality. In this grim world of “Isle of Dogs,” Nutmeg is a striking beauty and a force to be reckoned with. Johansson portrays her as a resilient noir heroine. When first meeting Chief, she assures him, “I’m fully grown, there’s no need for concern,” leaving no room for doubt about her strength and determination.

13. The Horse Whisperer (1998)

Prior to her notable role in “Ghost World,” Johansson gained recognition as the sorrowful teen Grace in Robert Redford’s film adaptation of Nicholas Evans’ novel. At just 13 years old when the movie was released, her performance in “The Horse Whisperer” left a profound impact on screenwriter Richard LaGravanese, who remarked that Johansson’s portrayal conveyed an emotional depth seemingly beyond her age. The film, while sentimental, showcases Johansson’s skillful handling of its emotional themes. However, even better opportunities awaited her.

12. Manny & Lo (1996)

When Johansson was just 11 years old, she portrayed the title character’s younger sister, named Lo (played by Aleksa Palladino). The two sisters had a turbulent upbringing, bouncing from one foster home to another. However, when Lo became pregnant, they met a kind and nurturing woman, Mary Kay Place, who worked at a baby clothes store. This employee ended up becoming a mother figure to them, providing them with the stability and care they had been lacking. In an unexpected turn of events, the sisters chose to kidnap her, but she willingly went along with them. Over time, an unlikely familial bond formed between the three, with Johansson serving as the film’s narrator. Despite being the youngest member of their makeshift family, Johansson’s character comes across as the warmest, most mature, and the one who best understands their situation.

11. Girl With a Pearl Earring (2003)

Director Peter Webber deliberately chose Johansson for her vibrant and intelligent demeanor, intending to suppress it. This unconventional approach paid off: Johansson excels in her role as a character who seldom speaks but is full of unexpressed thoughts. In “Girl With a Pearl Earring,” Johansson displays remarkable expressiveness despite the film’s silence. It’s fascinating to watch her performance now that she’s become a global celebrity.

10. Black Widow in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (2010–present)

As a film enthusiast, I couldn’t contain my excitement when I heard Black Widow was finally getting her own movie. Throughout the Marvel Cinematic Universe, she’s been an intriguing character, often serving as a counterpart to other heroes. From being Captain America’s sharp and witty ally, to the uneasy pseudo-love interest for the Hulk, and even forming a bond with Hawkeye that ultimately led to tragedy.

9. Asteroid City (2023)

As a passionate film enthusiast, I’m thrilled to share that Scarlett Johansson is gracing the silver screen once again in a movie produced post-pandemic. Contrasting her previous groundbreaking appearance in “Black Widow” with its unique simultaneous release in cinemas and Disney+, Johansson now stars in Wes Anderson’s latest production.

8. Match Point (2005)

I was cruising along quite contentedly until she entered the scene. Meeting Nola, my friend’s fiancée for the first time, left me utterly captivated. In her collaboration with Woody Allen in “Match Point,” Scarlett Johansson shone as a seductive and alluring woman who could easily steal your heart. Her portrayal of Nola was a far cry from her previous roles as an inexperienced ingénue in need of protection. Instead, she exuded assertiveness and maturity that made the screen sizzle with chemistry between her and Jonathan Rhys Meyers. The sexual tension and danger in their rapport were palpable, adding depth to a movie where Chris, our antihero, is driven by insatiable desires and ambition to commit heinous acts for Nola’s sake.

7. Vicky Cristina Barcelona (2008)

In the limelight was “Match Point,” which drew larger audiences and earned Penélope Cruz an Oscar, yet in the opinion of many, Johansson’s finest collaboration with Woody Allen is “Vicky Cristina Barcelona.” Playing the role of Cristina, Johansson embarks on a vacation to Barcelona with her friend Vicky (Rebecca Hall). Their friendship is put to the test when they both become attracted to the same man, Javier Bardem. While Vicky remains reserved and sensible, Cristina embraces passion in her life. Instead of portraying Cristina as a stereotype, Johansson brings depth to the character, creating a complex individual who yearns for a bohemian lifestyle but may be searching for something deeper. Allen’s films frequently feature characters grappling with uncertainty and dissatisfaction, yet Johansson breathed new life into this archetype by avoiding the quirks and mannerisms often associated with Allen’s characters.

6. Lucy (2014)

As a movie enthusiast, I’d like to share an intriguing way to rephrase that: You know, before we had the official Black Widow film in the MCU, there was this thrilling Luc Besson production titled “Lucy.” In it, Scarlett Johansson brilliantly showcases the abilities she honed in those Marvel movies. She plays the character of Lucy, a college student who, after an unexplainable incident involving a drug, gains the power to use her entire brain capacity. Instantly, she transforms into a genius and a formidable fighter!

5. Ghost World (2001)

In essence, Thora Birch initially takes the lead role in “Ghost World,” which is based on Terry Zwigoff’s adaptation of Daniel Clowes’ comic. However, Steve Buscemi and Johansson leave lasting impressions. Johansson, with her distinctive dry and sarcastic tone, brilliantly portrays Rebecca’s boredom and apathy. She is both amusing and caustic yet holds an unusual optimism and eagerness to develop, even if it means drifting apart from her friend. Unfortunately, by the film’s end, Johansson’s Rebecca becomes mostly absent, leaving a void in the narrative. The audience longs for her return.

4. Her (2013)

As a film enthusiast and someone who has followed the career of Scarlett Johansson with great interest, I cannot help but be fascinated by the unique turn of events that unfolded during the making of “Her.” Having read numerous articles and interviews about this intriguing behind-the-scenes story, I find myself in awe of Johansson’s incredible ability to embody a character so profoundly that it transcends our expectations.

3. Marriage Story (2019)

In “Marriage Story,” Noah Baumbach’s exploration of a divorce, much attention has been given to Adam Driver’s exceptional portrayal of Charlie, a theater director battling for child custody. However, Scarlett Johansson’s performance as Nicole, an actress who sacrificed her career for her husband, deserves equal recognition. Her depiction is understated yet impactful. In this film, there are no villains; instead, Baumbach and Johansson illustrate the challenges Nicole faces as she returns to Los Angeles, rebuilds her identity, and navigates motherhood and divorce. After a long tenure as Black Widow, Johansson’s portrayal of an ordinary woman dealing with a heart-wrenching separation is both refreshing and profound. While Driver delivers more prominent scenes, Johansson’s subtle yet powerful performance lingers – we experience the unspoken emotions Nicole endures.

2. Lost in Translation (2003)

A coming-out party for both its star and director, Lost in Translation was hardly the first film from Johansson or Sofia Coppola, but it’s one that still looms largest on both of their résumés. Coppola’s autobiographical film about a rudderless young woman, Charlotte (Johansson), wasting her life in Tokyo while her photographer husband (Giovanni Ribisi) pursues his career, harnessed the actress’ early appeal as a beautiful, unhappy seeker. Charlotte finds an unlikely friendship in an aging movie star, and while Bill Murray was widely lauded for his performance, it’s important to remember that Lost in Translation is a double act: He was her strongest scene partner to that point, while she helped bring out a tenderness he’d rarely shown onscreen. In Charlotte, Johansson perfected a youthful disillusionment that, once it was achieved, she’d quickly outgrow. More than 15 years later, though, this film remains one of her peaks.

1. Under the Skin (2013)

https://youtube.com/watch?v=watch?v=J7bAZCOk0Sc

“Acting in ‘Under the Skin’ as an emotionless character with no relatable connections was a complex task I found intriguing. Scarlett Johansson shares how this role marked a departure from her previous performances, which were magnetic, sarcastic or merely objects of affection. In the film, she plays an extraterrestrial who lures men into her van, leaving audiences guessing about her intentions. Earlier roles showcased Johansson’s ability to connect with audiences, but in ‘Under the Skin,’ she strips away that need and delivers a chilling performance of an efficient yet emotionless character.”

Grierson and Leitch frequently discuss films and run a podcast on cinema. Keep updated by following them on Twitter or checking out their website.

Read More

2024-07-22 19:15