15 Years Later, & It’s Time to Admit That This Iconic Sci-Fi Series with 95% on Rotten Tomatoes Had a Perfect Finale

by

Few finales in the annals of TV history have been as divisive yet iconic as “Daybreak,” the climactic three-part episode of a popular series that first aired in March 2009, more than a decade ago. This finale has left an indelible mark and continues to spark heated debates among its dedicated fanbase. Despite the show receiving widespread critical acclaim (boasting a 95% rating on Rotten Tomatoes) and pioneering gritty, contemporary science fiction television, its ending managed to polarize a significant portion of its fervent followers.

When the final episode was broadcast, many criticisms focused on its emphasis on spirituality, its rejection of technology, and the unresolved conclusions of certain storylines. People were surprised to discover that in the end, “God” was the explanation. However, with the passage of time and distance from initial viewer anticipation, it becomes clearer to evaluate. Reflecting now, detached from the intense pressure of fan expectations, it can’t just be considered but must be argued that “Daybreak” fell short of the highly acclaimed series “Battlestar Galactica“. For some viewers, it resonated thematically, offered emotional fulfillment, and completed a full circle of everything brave themes explored throughout the original show.

Battlestar Galactica Was Never Just About Survival

Nuts-And-Bolts Sci-Fi Ending Was Never in the Cards

Battlestar Galactica is a captivating space saga that follows the remaining fragments of humanity seeking to restore balance. Amidst the exhilarating and perilous FTL voyages, Moore’s reinvention was constantly playing a more profound role. The storyline, gradually unveiled by the writers, encompassed vast stretches of time, portraying a recurring tale of creation, uprising, and annihilation across millennia.

The core narrative, unveiled through scattered prophecies, dreams, and restored recollections of significant figures, paints a grand ancient tale: humans from their legendary homeland Kobol inventing the initial Cylons (the 13th Tribe, humanoid and equipped with resurrection abilities); a devastating conflict resulting in an evacuation, followed by the 12 Tribes establishing the Colonies while the 13th Tribe settled on their first destination, which they named Earth.

Right from its initial episodes, the science fiction series Battlestar Galactica employed its futuristic setting as a backdrop to delve into intricate, sometimes challenging themes concerning human nature, governance, faith, and self-identity. The show transcended the conventional narrative of fleeing and finding a new world to avoid the destruction wrought by machines, instead focusing on avoiding the disastrous errors committed in the past. Regrettably, “Earth 1,” established by Cylons, mirrored this cycle of repeated mistakes.

In time, they neglected their past, developed advanced robotics, and ultimately fabricated the Cylon Centurions. It was expected that these creations would eventually revolt, which led to a devastating nuclear war that left their planet barren 2,000 years prior to the story’s central events. The sole survivors of this catastrophe were the “Final Five,” who were Cylon scientists from Earth 1 and had been striving to recreate their lost resurrection capabilities.

Anticipating the recurring pattern, they initiated a thousand-year voyage using sublight speed to alert their human relatives about impending danger, but unfortunately, they arrived after the colonies had already been embroiled in war with their own rebellious creations (the First Cylon War). The intricate and profound mythology unveiled through recovered memories was not mere background; it was a fundamental and deeply ingrained message within the show’s universe that humanity and their creations were trapped in a sort of karmic cycle.

Fervent followers of the show should be familiar with the chilling phrase, “This has happened before, and this will happen again,” which resonates throughout the series. Though the quote’s origin is J.M. Barrie’s Peter Pan, it has become inextricably linked with Battlestar Galactica, representing the cyclical nature of human behavior. Consequently, any “victory” for the Galactica’s fleet would necessitate more than just discovering a sanctuary; it would call for a profound break from this age-old, destructive cycle.

The series wasn’t simply a hunt for Earth; it delved into questioning humanity’s worthiness to persist. By incorporating themes of faith, religion, and the mystical, the show transcended typical science fiction stereotypes. From Laura Roslin’s prophetic utterances, Starbuck’s enigmatic fate, to Gaius Baltar and Six’s shared visions, the show’s persistent exploration of spiritual and philosophical concepts ruled out a straightforward, technology-focused conclusion.

Deciphering The Much-Debated Finale & Moore’s Intentions

In the twilight of “Battlestar Galactica,” as I found myself watching the penultimate episodes unfold, it was clear that survival hung by a thread for our Colonial fleet and their unlikely Cylon allies. The iconic Galactica itself was crippled, its glory days numbered. Their very existence teetered on the edge of oblivion, hanging in the balance of a high-stakes gambit: an all-or-nothing assault on Cavil’s heavily fortified Cylon Colony – his basestar – to rescue Hera, the rare hybrid child who could potentially unlock our future.

In my perspective, the obliteration of the primary Resurrection Hub marked a permanent setback for the Cylons, turning our last stand into an unavoidable endgame. As the pieces of the puzzle crumbled, Starbuck’s (Katee Sackhoff) cryptic reading of musical notes as jump coordinates offered the slimmest glimmer of hope – a possible new refuge, perhaps even the final chapter in our tumultuous saga. The conflict surrounding the Colony was merciless, culminating in Cavil’s defeat.

When his efforts to obtain resurrection technology through Hera are stopped by disagreements among the Final Five, he decides drastically to end his life with an exclamation of “Frak”. As the Colony and Galactica suffer severe damage, Starbuck performs a final, mysterious jump using coordinates derived from music shared between her and Hera. Instead of leading the fleet to a familiar destination, she guides them to a new, inhabitable world – our Earth, about 150,000 years in the past.

Here’s where the debate about the ending unfolds: Admiral Adama (Edward James Olmos) guides the survivors, both humans and allied Cylons, in making a joint decision to forgo their sophisticated technology. As a result, the entire fleet is guided towards the sun. They opt to disperse across the planet, leading simple lives, and blending with the indigenous primitive human communities that are already there.

The closing sequence might appear satisfactory, but many enthusiastic fans who anticipated a more fulfilling ending felt let down. Some even shared their discontent on online platforms, with one fan commenting, “It’s also worth mentioning that to break the cycle, you need understanding of the cycle itself, which would perish within a few generations without technology to preserve knowledge from one generation to another.

Some viewers found Starbuck’s sudden disappearance at the end of the series strange, as expressed in a Reddit conversation: “Starbuck just vanishing seemed odd,” one fan put it. However, this seemingly abrupt departure, which some criticized as Deus ex machina, was actually a fitting conclusion to storylines that had been subtly developed throughout the show. The creator of the series, Moore, viewed it as a heartfelt farewell to Starbuck’s character. In an interview with a journalist, he stated: “I felt it was the ideal way to say goodbye to this character.

Battlestar Galactica’s Legacy & the Finale’s Place Within It

Television is indisputable, as the series brought a revolutionary approach to its genre by delving into darker, grittier, and more character-focused storytelling. It tackled mature themes such as authoritarianism, terrorism, civil liberties, and the ethics of war with a level of gravity and complexity seldom seen on network or basic cable TV. The show’s writers skillfully interwove these contemporary political concerns within its science fiction narrative.

In the wake of September 11, this television series struck a chord particularly deeply. Its enduring impact is owed to its intricately crafted characters such as Adama, Roslin, Starbuck, Apollo, and Baltar. Unlike stereotypical heroes or villains, these figures were complex personalities grappling with moral dilemmas and internal conflicts that resonated deeply as they mirrored human experiences. The intense discussions and critiques sparked by the episode “Daybreak” serve to highlight the show’s influence. However, in a 2009 interview with , David Eick, the creator and executive producer of Battlestar Galactica, expressed contentment with the series’ conclusion, stating that:

the recurring pattern. The ending made it clear that while futuristic technology and space travel often depict a distant future, Battlestar Galactica is a series that views this setting as an ancient history of our present-day Earth.

In their final conversation, Baltar admits recognizing a recurring design and poses the question, “Is it possible that all of this will happen again?” To which Six offers a reassuring response, “I sure hope not this time.” This leaves the audience with a blend of tentative optimism and fulfillment, as the story concludes.

Read More

2025-05-18 23:21