10 Must-See Fantasy Movies Ranked by Critic Gene Siskel

by

Noted film critic and author Gene Siskel, recognized primarily for his movie reviews alongside Roger Ebert, applauded a wide range of films throughout his career across different genres such as horror, comedy, drama, and others. Occasionally, he deemed blockbusters among the finest works of the 20th century, yet frequently drew attention to lesser-known international projects that might have gone unnoticed in the U.S.

Although the journalist had a knack for watching movies across various genres, he often found himself drawn to intricate family dramas or films with layered relationship plots. However, it’s worth mentioning that some of his favorite films from the past century were fantastical tales, and this collection of ten will be highlighted in the upcoming article. Keep in mind, though, that the definition of fantasy might need to be stretched a bit in this context, considering Siskel’s preferences.

Released in 1976

Title “The Seven-Per-Cent Solution” might not immediately strike one as a typical fantasy movie. Unlike those filled with creatures such as orcs and elves, this film intertwines fiction with the renowned psychoanalyst Sigmund Freud. To add to its allure, it boasts the star-studded cast of Alan Arkin, Nicol Williamson, Vanessa Redgrave, and Laurence Olivier, among others.

As a cinephile, I must share that in 1977, the enigmatic film I adore was nominated for two prestigious Academy Awards – Best Costume Design and Best Adapted Screenplay. However, despite the nominations, it didn’t take home either of those coveted statuettes. Critic Siskel ranked this movie among his top 10 for 1976, but fellow critic Ebert held a different opinion.

Released in 1977

One significant movie that won over both Siskel and Ebert was initially titled “A New Hope“, now more commonly known as Star Wars. Even half a century after its debut, this film remains widely beloved by viewers from all age groups. Actors like Mark Hamill, Carrie Fisher, and Harrison Ford have become icons of popular culture as a result.

Star Wars skillfully combines elements of science fiction, fantasy, and action into an engaging storyline that maximizes the special effects technology of its time. This groundbreaking film has since developed into a multi-billion dollar franchise, with fans worldwide commemorating “May the Fourth be with you” on May 4th every year – a playful nod to the iconic phrase.

Released in 1979

Before F.W. Murnau’s daring attempt at Nosferatu, Werner Herzog reimagined the story in Nosferatu the Vampyre. Similar to other adaptations of the gothic horror/Dracula narrative, this film portrays a chilling Count captivated by a stunning mortal woman. This movie is also one that Roger Ebert and Gene Siskel highly praised.

While some devoted fantasy enthusiasts might question if this fits the genre, given Siskel’s apparent leanings towards more realistic narratives, we’re stretching the definition of fantasy a bit. For those eager to explore further, I recommend checking out the 1922 film titled “Nosferatu: A Symphony of Horror“.

Released in 1979

Just like the movie “The Seven-Per-Cent Solution,” this film combines fact and fantasy in a thrilling journey of imagination. Unlike the Cyndi Lauper song of the same name, “Time After Time” follows British author H.G. Wells as he constructs a time machine, which is subsequently utilized by the notorious Jack the Ripper for escape. The film stars Malcolm McDowell, Mary Steenburgen, and David Warner.

Although it might seem more akin to science fiction than traditional fantasy, “Time After Time” effectively blends elements like escapism, good versus evil, and underdog heroes, to name a few. It shares some traits with “Back to the Future,” yet maintains the emotion and originality of a captivating novel.

Released in 1986

The Fly appears to be just another cheesy ’80s movie with an eye-catching poster, but beneath its stylish exterior lies a remarkable contribution to the horror genre. This is largely due to the creative brilliance of …and the captivating acting performance of a young Jeff Goldblum.

In this intriguing vintage tale, a researcher appears to accomplish teleportation, only to start transforming into a grotesque combination of man and fly. Although the plot might initially seem far-fetched, Cronenberg aficionados are well aware that his outlandish concepts are often brought to life with chilling realism and profound subtext. For movie enthusiasts seeking a captivating film for their night’s viewing, The Fly is an excellent selection.

Released in 1988

Acclaimed for films such as “Back to the Future” and “Forrest Gump”, he also left an indelible mark on global childhoods through his detective comedy/fantasy “Who Framed Roger Rabbit”. This seemingly lighthearted addition to his portfolio actually delivers a powerful blend of visual and emotional impact.

1988 saw both Siskel and Ebert hailing Who Framed Roger Rabbit as one of the year’s finest films, with Siskel going so far as to include it among the top 10 movies of the 1980s. This groundbreaking film was also among the pioneers in seamlessly blending animation with live action, managing to avoid appearing tacky or excessive. In his review, Siskel was particularly impressed by the innovative techniques used to bring the movie to life, describing it as “more vibrant and exhilarating than most cartoon productions we’ve ever encountered.

Released in 1991

Regarding animations, there’s an enchanting fairy-tale that made history by being nominated for Best Picture at the 1992 Academy Awards. This movie revolves around a young woman who opts to remain in the Beast’s castle to save her father, and during her stay, she develops affection not only for the castle inhabitants but also for its enigmatic master.

This cherished animated film boasts an exceptional soundtrack by veteran Disney composer Alan Menken, a fact that earned it the endorsement from Ebert and Siskel. The critic claimed the movie had revitalized musicals, which he believed were extinct for “the past 20 years” before its premiere, giving them a new lease on life.

Released in 1995

Babe” is a movie that left critics across the board astonished, as it was nominated for Best Picture at the 1996 Academy Awards. At first glance, it may seem like just a simple children’s film about a young pig; however, it unfolds into a heartwarming story of friendship, forgiveness, and surmounting obstacles. As for its categorization within fantasy, the main character, Babe, is able to converse with other animals during his journey to become a herder. In essence, that’s all you need to know.

It’s interesting to note that while critics have given Babe a high score of 97%, the audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes stands at 67%. This film may not appeal to everyone due to its leisurely pace and farm-based narrative. However, for those open to investing their time in this heartwarming tale, they will find it to be a delightful portrayal of living compassionately, a message that seems particularly relevant in these times.

Released in 1998

In contemporary times, Pleasantville tends not to receive the accolades it merits. Featuring a young Tobey Maguire and Reese Witherspoon, this movie narrates the tale of two siblings who step into the world of a 1950s television series, leading to outcomes that are frequently surprising. The film skillfully delves into social concerns while providing breathtaking visuals as well.

In essence, “Pleasantville” isn’t flawless, not by a long shot, and the conclusion, in particular, fails to tie up some loose ends. However, it is a thought-provoking—albeit somewhat simplified—portrayal of the power of being true to oneself over conforming to societal norms. Moreover, the film delves into the imaginative exploration of what it signifies to inhabit an alternate reality and whether such a life holds less significance than any other.

Released in 1998

In a surprising turn of events at the 1999 Academy Awards, it was “Shakespeare in Love” that outshone “Saving Private Ryan” for the Best Picture award. Both films were highly praised by critics Siskel and Ebert, who also ranked “Pleasantville” among the best movies of 1998. However, this doesn’t diminish the exceptional filmmaking prowess of “Shakespeare in Love”.

In a delightful interweaving of fact and imagination, the movie Shakespeare in Love portrays a romantic liaison between the authentic William Shakespeare and the fictional Viola De Lesseps. Their love affair, initially disguised as she posing as a male actor, serves as the catalyst for Shakespeare to pen Romeo and Juliet, and further fuels his creativity in composing future plays. Despite debates surrounding its historical accuracy, this film has consistently demonstrated that it is worthy of its praise.

Read More

2025-05-28 01:42