Why Shiny Manaphy from Pokemon Home is Not Worth the Pain of Playing BDSP

by

Engaging promotions and obstacles contribute significantly to the enjoyment provided by Pokemon Home within the franchise. Nevertheless, the latest free gift for completing a Pokemon Home Pokedex lacks appeal, despite the adorable nature of Shiny Manaphy.

In the world of Pokémon, certain mythical creatures are harder to obtain than others, with Shiny Manaphy being particularly elusive. This is due in part to its unique distribution in Pokémon Ranger back in 2006, which made it hard to come by for many players. Additionally, until the latest Pokémon Home event, there had never been an instance where a Shiny Manaphy was distributed as a guaranteed catch.

At present, upon successfully filling out the Pokedex for the region of Hisui in Pokémon Home, players will be rewarded with a Shiny Enamorus. Additionally, trainers who accomplish the task of completing the Sinnoh Pokedex within Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl games will receive a Shiny Manaphy as a gift.

Regrettably, this adorable gift isn’t worth the investment. The BDSP remake is one of the least enjoyable games to play in recent times, and not even a Shadow Mewtwo would compensate for the trouble of completing the Sinnoh Pokédex.

BDSP is forgettable for a reason

2021 saw a somewhat underwhelming launch of Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl. With a 73% Metacritic score and a 3.1 rating on Google Reviews, these titles faced criticism for their outdated graphics, overly bright color schemes, and disappointing quality-of-life upgrades compared to the original Diamond and Pearl games.

Following impressive revamps such as Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire, or New Pokemon Snap, revisiting Sinnoh seemed less lavish and slower paced, and the gaming experience appeared more of a tedious task rather than an enjoyable journey.

As soon as Pokemon Legends: Arceus dropped a few months back, old memories of Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl seemed to fade away like ghosts in the wind. I found myself lost for hours in the captivating open-world of the Hisui region, marveling at its breathtaking visuals.

Due to this, numerous trainers struggled to complete the game or progress beyond a couple of dozens of Pokémon entries in the BDSP Pokedex.

Players agree Shiny Manaphy just isn’t worth it

After the Pokemon Home challenge introduction on social media, fans have been expressing their reluctance to revisit BDSP. One enthusiast even compared their Hisui Pokemon collection against their Sinnoh one and voiced, “Looks like my chance at a shiny Manaphy is still far off.

Chat I don’t think I’m getting shiny Manaphy any time soon

— Shiny Catherine (@shinyycatherine) January 28, 2025

Many others in the comments concurred swiftly, as one individual stated, “I too have 16…”, while another chipped in, “Playing Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl doesn’t seem worth it for a Shiny Manaphy.

1. The feedback from players mirrored similar sentiments: Many found it not worthwhile, despite the rarity of the prize. I totally concur. The thought of playing through the entire game, enduring Legendary and Mythical encounters, trading for items my version lacks in a game I disliked seems far too laborious.

2. Players’ reactions generally shared the same sentiments: Few found it worth the effort, even given the rarity of the prize. I completely concur. The notion of having to complete the entire game, encounter Legendary and Mythical characters, trade for items my version doesn’t have in a game that I couldn’t stand feels incredibly tiresome.

3. Players’ responses largely expressed similar opinions: A small number considered it worthwhile, despite the rarity of the prize. I wholeheartedly concur. The idea of playing through the entire game, dealing with Legendary and Mythical encounters, trading for items my version lacks in a game that I found unbearable seems incredibly tedious.

4. Players’ feedback generally conveyed the same sentiments: A limited number found it worth the effort, even given the rarity of the prize. I entirely concur. The thought of playing through the entire game, dealing with Legendary and Mythical characters, trading for items my version doesn’t have in a game that I couldn’t stand seems incredibly tiresome.

5. Players’ reactions mostly shared the same sentiments: Only a few found it worthwhile, despite the rarity of the prize. I completely concur. The idea of playing through the entire game, dealing with Legendary and Mythical encounters, trading for items my version lacks in a game that I couldn’t stand seems incredibly tedious.

Spending hours on a Pokémon that will merely remain idle, confined within a storage box forever, is essentially wasting time.

For individuals daring enough to tackle the challenge of obtaining a Shiny Manaphy through trading, they can boast about their achievement when flaunting it among friends. However, I prefer to observe from afar, as the effort doesn’t seem worth it for me – my sights are set on pursuing a Shiny Enamorus instead.

Read More

2025-01-29 02:23