Why Modern Final Fantasy Side Quests Are Leaving Players Confused and Frustrated

by

Discussions about the beloved video game franchise, Final Fantasy, often revolve around its captivating narratives, beautiful visuals, and intricate characters. However, it’s also known for its challenging side quests that have become a staple of the series. As fans explore both classic and modern versions, they’ve noticed an evolution in these side quests, leading to debates about their current state. A post by user SertanejoRaiz on a gaming discussion platform presents a persuasive viewpoint suggesting that contemporary side quests lack the charm and difficulty of earlier games like FF XII. By comparing the immersive nature of older quests with the more hand-holding style in newer titles like XV and XVI, SertanejoRaiz raises questions about whether modern design decisions are diminishing the nostalgic and satisfying questing experience that older games excelled at. Let’s delve into what fans are discussing about this very topic!

Summary

  • Many fans believe that modern Final Fantasy games lack the depth and engagement found in older titles.
  • There’s a prevalent theme of dissatisfaction with constant markers and hand-holding in game design, making it less rewarding to complete quests.
  • The pressure from trophies and quests lists in modern games creates a compulsive need to finish everything, detracting from the enjoyment.
  • Many gamers long for a return to organic quest discovery and the satisfaction of connecting the dots on their own.

The Charm of Older Side Quests

In today’s era of advanced markers and guided navigation, the charm of older side quests, such as those found in Final Fantasy XII, stands out vividly among fans who fondly recall the struggle of solving problems independently. SertanejoRaiz highlighted a specific side quest where players had to administer medicine to a sick character. Unlike modern games that guide you step-by-step, this quest required players to engage with the game world, converse with NPCs, and recall past conversations to progress. This old-fashioned style of questing evokes a sense of nostalgia, mimicking the days when completing a quest felt like a personal triumph. As SertanejoRaiz put it, “There’s something rewarding about being self-reliant!” On the other hand, players express disappointment with modern games that seem to spoon-feed information. Instead of exploration and discovery, these games provide clear instructions on maps, diluting the sense of personal achievement. A player explained that the experience feels more like checking off items on a to-do list rather than embarking on an exciting quest, thus diminishing the excitement of game exploration.

Design Preferences & Conflicts

In a nutshell, while some discussions about game design resonate with many players, not everyone agrees. For instance, some players find pleasure in classic quests, but appreciate that modern designs help them avoid frustration. One user mentioned, “Without enough map markers, other players might get confused or forget.” This observation highlights a delicate balance in game design: the need to balance challenge and accessibility. Players like SertanejoRaiz seek an immersive experience, while others prefer clear-cut quests. This division is evident between those who enjoy the thrill of mystery and those who might grow frustrated with aimless wandering for extended periods. While some view map markers as a crutch, others see them as essential guidance in today’s vast RPG worlds.

The Pressure of Completionism

As gaming trophies and achievements have become more prevalent, many players find themselves driven to finish every mission. In contrast to earlier games where finishing was satisfying without worrying about missing something, modern gamers face a conundrum: they have greater chances for exploration and interaction, but this increased freedom brings the burden of completionism. A user once stated, “Completing older games without doing everything didn’t seem so bad; just completing the game still felt great.” Today, however, players are often reminded of incomplete side quests, transforming the experience from one of discovery to one of obligation. The thrill of stumbling upon a side quest naturally is overshadowed by the fear of missing out. Players feel pressured to pursue every side quest to “keep up,” which can turn the excitement of adventure into a tedious task.

Future of Side Quests: A Happy Medium?

Even though opinions differ, this discussion has unearthed a promising possibility: envision a realm where gamers could switch quest indicators on or off! SertanejoRaiz proposes that the optimal course of action could be granting players the freedom to carve their own route. One user proposed an intriguing viewpoint, mentioning Octopath Traveler 2, where markers for quests were accessible from the givers but left the path to complete them unclear. “The core spirit of adventuring can be preserved,” they emphasized, as players would still depend on their own instincts to traverse the world. This could be the key to creating a gaming experience tailored to individual tastes! Players craving an immersive, challenging narrative could delve into the traditional atmosphere, while those preferring ease could opt for a more structured journey. Choices like these would not only cater to both groups but also foster deeper conversations among players, ensuring that nostalgia and contemporary gameplay contribute to a unified and inclusive tale.

Discussions about alterations in side quests within contemporary Final Fantasy games revolve around a crucial issue concerning player control and enjoyment. Are we seeking immersive involvement, as was popular during gaming’s golden age, or is ease our ultimate objective? The community reflects a diverse array of opinions, all united by their passion for Final Fantasy. As we converse and argue about the intricacies of quest construction, there’s a sense of camaraderie in our shared desire to see the franchise evolve while maintaining the appeal that initially captivated numerous fans. In the end, it appears that achieving a harmony between challenge and assistance—the ideal combination that appeals to both newcomers and veterans—may be the key to preserving and strengthening the legacy of Final Fantasy for future generations!

Read More

2025-03-12 19:31