Watching Straight Men Watch Heated Rivalry

by

During a live video recording in late December, the hosts of the hockey podcast Empty Netters – known for their in-depth analysis of the game – were captivated by the finale of the show Heated Rivalry. They watched with excitement as Shane Hollander and Ilya Rozanov, the show’s gay hockey players, finally confessed their love after years of secret romance. “Rozy’s breaking down!” exclaimed Dan Powers as Ilya passionately spoke to Shane. His brother, Chris, frantically asked if they had subtitles. When the characters finally said “I love you,” all three hosts – Dan, Chris, and their producer Sean Buffini – were visibly shocked. Dan gasped, Chris grabbed his hair, and Dan excitedly commented on a kiss. Overwhelmed by the moment, Chris jumped off the couch and out of view, saying, “Don’t look at me!”

American culture feels very divided right now, stuck between conservative viewpoints and progressive ideals. You see this online, with people like Ben Shapiro criticizing liberal content and commentators reacting strongly to current events. However, the “Heated Rivalry” reaction videos show a different side – genuine joy and excitement when two gay athletes share a moment. Because so much of what we watch is experienced alone through personalized feeds, these reaction videos feel like a digital version of sharing experiences with others. They cover everything from first-time listens to classic songs to reactions to sports highlights and shocking reveals, offering a sense of connection. While many things get this treatment, the “Heated Rivalry” videos have sparked an unusually large number of reactions, suggesting they’ve really resonated with people.

Unlike many TV adaptations, especially even shows like Bridgerton, Heated Rivalry sticks very closely to the original romance novel’s plot, without adding extra storylines. It quickly establishes a strong intimate connection between the main characters, Ilya and Shane. Within the first fifteen minutes, there’s a very explicit scene of intimacy, and soon after, they are naked together. The show doesn’t shy away from detailed and prolonged sex scenes, which is rare on television – most shows only hint at intimacy before cutting away. Viewers who have already watched Heated Rivalry often enjoy seeing the shocked reactions of first-time viewers, experiencing a kind of second-hand thrill. There’s a playful dramatic irony at play – those who’ve seen it know what to expect, and watching others discover it is part of the fun, like anticipating a mother’s reaction while her daughter sits beside her!

A lot of the appeal of this show seems to be watching straight men react to it. The Empty Netters podcast typically gets a few thousand views per episode, with popular ones reaching 20,000. Their Heated Rivalry recaps are even more popular, with hundreds of thousands of views each. Another hockey podcast, What Chaos!, has seen a similar increase in viewers when covering the show, and this “watch-along” trend has spread to other commentators. TikTok is full of videos of straight men reacting, and they all follow a similar pattern: the men start out skeptical or unsure of what they’re about to see. They often struggle to articulate their thoughts. Common questions include confusion about the dynamics of the relationships – things like, “Can gay men do missionary?” or observations about who seems to be taking which role. Underlying this unfamiliarity is an unspoken question: is it okay for them to even be watching this, and does enjoying it somehow challenge their masculinity?

Instead of being uncomfortable, the straight men watching Heated Rivalry become genuinely invested in the story unfolding alongside Shane and Ilya’s. What starts as playful teasing quickly turns into enthusiastic support – they even adapt a hockey chant to cheer on the intimate scenes. The reaction is particularly strong when a hockey player kisses his boyfriend after winning the Stanley Cup; the hosts of one popular reaction vlog, Nick and Cory, visibly perk up. They’re clearly captivated, yelling with excitement when Ilya announces he’s going to Shane’s cottage. Unlike celebrities who struggle with even mild displays of physicality, these men are openly enjoying the film and, surprisingly, helping to normalize it. When Howard Stern suggests the show to his co-host, Robin Quivers, it gains even more mainstream attention.

Reaction videos go beyond simply letting viewers release their emotions. Commentators offer insightful, and often critical, analysis of the show itself. For example, Nick and Cory focus on small details in character growth and complex emotions, while the creators of What Chaos! concentrate on the authenticity of the hockey scenes and the sport’s traditionally tough image. These videos represent just a portion of the wider world of Heated Rivalry reaction content, which includes diverse perspectives from women and LGBTQ+ individuals experiencing a range of emotions – from excitement and disbelief to skepticism and even arousal. However, in 2026, there’s something especially interesting about watching straight men react to this particular show.

A common debate about the current state of America – ten years after the start of the Trump era, with some commentators claiming progressive values have disappeared – centers on whether focusing too much on identity and supporting LGBTQ+ families during the Obama years triggered a conservative backlash, potentially reversing decades of social progress. However, every time someone unexpectedly enjoys seeing same-sex affection – like a viewer reacting positively to a kiss on the show Heated Rivalry – it offers a small glimmer of hope. There’s something hopeful in watching people, especially those who might not normally seek it out, engage with shows like Heated Rivalry. It suggests that the progress made over the past 80 years might not be completely undone, and that a return to rigid traditional values isn’t inevitable. Even something as simple as a hockey commentator enthusiastically acknowledging someone’s appearance can make that possibility feel a little more real.

Read More

2026-01-19 20:55