The Pitt Season-Premiere Recap: Another Day in Paradise

by

We first met Dr. Michael “Robby” Rabinavitch in the pilot episode of The Pitt, arriving at Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center to the song “Baby” by Robert Bradley’s Blackwater Surprise. He was dealing with significant PTSD, but initially seemed calm and in control. The second season of this popular and critically acclaimed medical drama starts similarly, with Robby heading to the hospital for work. However, things feel much more unsettling this time. Ten months after a particularly difficult shift, Robby has taken up riding motorcycles – and isn’t wearing a helmet, despite being an emergency room doctor. The song accompanying his arrival is now “Better Off Without You” by The Clarks, filled with lyrics about self-preservation and moving on. As his Fourth of July shift begins, I’m still very concerned about Robby’s well-being. A middle-aged man suddenly embracing motorcycle riding feels like a clear sign he’s struggling, and that’s just common sense.

Robby doesn’t seem drastically different at first, though he does appear more easily frustrated. I’m hoping he’s received some therapy to deal with the trauma he experienced last season. His decision to take a three-month break could be a good sign that he’s prioritizing his mental well-being over work, but his impulsive trip to Alberta is concerning. We’ll have to see how things play out. Right now, though, he just needs to get through his shift – and at 7:00 A.M., that already seems like a challenge.

Things at PTMC are already chaotic as usual. The waiting room is packed with patients who look exhausted, injured, and, frankly, not very pleasant. (I actually laughed when Robby said it looked “manageable.”) The emergency department is completely full, and we’re being rushed from patient to patient as the day shift doctors get started. It’s good to be back at “The Pitt” – and the Pitt in general. While the Fourth of July holiday and the intense heat will likely add to the craziness later, it all feels pretty normal so far. However, Robby soon realizes this shift will be more stressful than he expected, with two new issues quickly arising. As I predicted, just getting through this shift won’t be easy.

Robby is being replaced by Dr. Baran Al-Hashimi, who comes highly recommended by the VA and has previously worked with doctors Samira Mohan and Mel King. She’s already started training the residents and medical students with practice scenarios. Dr. Shen and Nurse Lena let Robby know that Dr. Al-Hashimi is very interested in using artificial intelligence in hospital management and is quite strict about following procedures, which immediately frustrates Robby. This sets up a major conflict for the season. The episode, directed by John Wells and written by R. Scott Gemmill, cleverly uses a patient with a stab wound to highlight the contrasting approaches to medicine between Robby and Dr. Al-Hashimi, showcasing the show’s efficient character development.

Robby encourages the residents and interns to be independent and make their own choices, trusting their instincts and thinking outside the box. He’s even willing to attempt unconventional, potentially dangerous procedures – in this case, a risky lung rotation to control bleeding, performed by a fellow and Dr. Yolanda Garcia. This approach clashes with Dr. Al-Hashimi, who prefers to follow established rules and protocols. Throughout the trauma case, they repeatedly disagree; she favors a cautious, step-by-step method, even when a more daring solution might be necessary.

We have a lot of doubts about Al-Hashimi, and we strongly support Robby. It’s frustrating that she doesn’t seem to understand what everyone experienced last year. Beyond her attempts to gain influence, her promotion of AI is concerning, especially since Gloria, a popular hospital administrator, already supports her. But perhaps the biggest issue is her dislike of calling the ED “The Pitt” – it feels disrespectful.

Despite initial concerns, Dr. Al-Hashimi is a capable doctor, and Dr. Mohan is eager to work with her again. It’s too early to dismiss her, and the episode strongly suggests there’s more to her story than meets the eye. A significant storyline begins when a baby, roughly a month old, is found in the waiting room restroom. This is complicated because leaving a baby under 28 days old allows for anonymous drop-off under Safe Haven laws, while anything older is considered abandonment. No one saw anyone bring a baby into the hospital, so they’re running tests to ensure the child is healthy. Dr. Al-Hashimi, Dr. Mohan, and Nurse Jesse review the initial results, which are positive. However, Dr. Al suddenly becomes visibly disturbed. This reaction is surprising, considering everything else that happens in the emotionally charged pediatric ward—a place the narrator clearly dislikes—but it’s still concerning. We’ll likely discover the reason for Dr. Al’s behavior as the season progresses.

There’s a lot of mixed emotion in the ER today. It might be Dr. Robby’s last shift for a while, but it’s also Dr. Frank Langdon’s first day back after ten months. He was in rehab and counseling dealing with a benzodiazepine addiction, and everyone knows it. Lena jokingly calls him the ‘prodigal son’ as he walks in – you can still feel the tension from when Santos revealed his struggles to Robby, and Robby lost it. Honestly, most of us are just glad to see him. Dr. Mel King is absolutely thrilled – I’ve missed her awkward enthusiasm! Langdon’s definitely flawed, but I’ll always have a soft spot for him because of how he mentored Mel. It’s good to have him back, even with all the baggage.

Honestly, seeing Santos back wasn’t great for her, and she’s been keeping her distance. She’s totally swamped with her second-year residency – basically drowning in paperwork, and Al-Hashimi keeps bugging her about it, which doesn’t help! On top of everything, she’s got this really tough case with a nine-year-old named Kylie. Kylie came in with a cut on her chin after a fall, but Santos and Nurse Perlah quickly noticed other bruises and signs of older injuries. When Kylie’s urine showed more blood than urine, Santos immediately suspected abuse. Thankfully, Robby and Al-Hashimi agreed she should call social services, but that means things are about to get really complicated – and heartbreaking, probably.

Dealing with Langdon was just another headache for Robby. It was high on his list of annoyances, right below ‘avoiding a public outburst against Langdon.’ Robby was mostly furious when he unexpectedly ran into him. He’d hoped to avoid another confrontation for at least one more day, but here Langdon was. Robby could barely tolerate looking at him, but Langdon seemed determined to apologize and talk things through. Robby immediately refused, and sent Langdon to work in the triage area, hoping they wouldn’t cross paths again.

It’s alright if Robby and Langdon have some tension – they’ll likely work things out. Hopefully, it will be a good, honest conversation, even if a little intense. Just because Robby is giving Langdon the silent treatment doesn’t stop Langdon from trying to make things right. He bumps into an old patient, Louie, who we met last season. Louie’s back with a serious tooth infection and fluid buildup in his abdomen. Langdon admits he stole some of Louie’s medication previously, explaining his own addiction and apologizing. Louie accepts, likely because he understands addiction himself. While not every apology will be so easily forgiven, this allows Langdon to start treating Louie. He instructs Dr. Whitaker and her two new medical students – the overly confident Ogilvy and the seemingly uninterested Joy – to drain the fluid from Louie’s abdomen. This is Louie’s third time needing this procedure in six months, and he’s really struggling.

A new nursing school graduate, Emma, came to the emergency department to learn from Dana. This is particularly notable because Dana was recently considering leaving PTMC after a difficult period – she was assaulted by a patient and then worked during the mass shooting at PittFest. While she took some time off to recover, Dana says she’s like a reliable, experienced horse that always returns to the stable. Emma is incredibly fortunate to be mentored by Dana, and she should definitely make the most of this opportunity!

Emma’s first hour on the job isn’t glamorous – it involves tasks like taking rectal temperatures and assisting a man named Digby who is experiencing homelessness. She quickly learns the nurses’ safe word (“hula hoop”). Even with these less-than-ideal moments, Dana shows Emma that even small acts of kindness – like providing soap, water, and basic respect – can greatly impact a patient. Dana delivers this lesson while still being her usual, no-nonsense self – chewing gum, speaking with a strong accent, and keeping everyone, including the doctors, in line. It’s great to have her back after everything she’s been through, but I’m still concerned about how a long shift might affect her. Happy Fourth of July, though?

Discharge Papers

Dr. Cassie McKay is feeling increasingly frustrated and preoccupied, and spends much of the hour attending to Mr. Williams, who injured his wrist and nose in a fall. Initially, his behavior reminds Dr. McKay of another patient, Doug Driscoll, but she soon realizes there’s more to his distress. He seems deeply confused, leading her to suspect a possible head injury might be the cause.

Mel King is really preoccupied today. She’s so lost in thought that she doesn’t even notice someone trying to flirt with her – and that’s not unusual for her. However, this time her distraction has a specific cause: she’s facing a malpractice lawsuit and has a deposition scheduled for later. She’s understandably upset about it.

I’m really feeling for Mohan right now! She’s finishing her residency, and just accepted a job at a hospital closer to her mom in New Jersey, which was a big step. But then everything changed – her mom sold her house, is getting married super quickly to someone she barely knows, and they’re planning to go on a year-long cruise! It’s a lot to process, and I can only imagine how thrown off Mohan must be after making all those plans.

Victoria Javadi is still in medical school, trying to decide on a specialty. Her mother, Dr. Shamsi, keeps pressuring her to choose a surgical residency, even though Victoria’s 21st birthday is almost here – it’s really quite inconsiderate.

Donnie Donavan has had quite the change of pace! He’s become a new father and is now working as a Nurse Practitioner, confidently managing emergency room triage. It’s a major step up for him this season.

Robby is taking his sabbatical at Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump, a historic site in Alberta, Canada. Feel free to look it up – it’s quite interesting!

College life at Pitt is already pretty demanding, so it’s great to know that season two of the show is happening and that we’re already guaranteed a third season. It takes some of the pressure off!

• New season, new glasses for Dr. Robby. Now, that’s what I call fan service, baby.

Read More

2026-01-09 05:56