Seven Cozy Fall Movies, Like Practical Magic, That Are Perfect If You’re Too Chicken For Horror

It’s okay if you’re not into scary movies and slashers this fall. Many people prefer relaxing with a warm drink, comfortable clothes, and a feel-good movie that’s as comforting as the scent of autumn.

If you enjoy the warm, romantic, and enchanting feel of Practical Magic, here are seven movies that are perfect for cozy fall evenings in 2025. While they might not be critical darlings, these films capture the same atmosphere, beautiful colors, and nostalgic feeling – they’re the perfect comfort viewing! Just light a candle, grab a blanket, and settle in for a movie night as relaxing as sitting by a fireplace.

Practical Magic (1998)

If you’re looking for the perfect fall movie, I always come back to Practical Magic. Seriously, few films nail that cozy, slightly sad autumn vibe quite like it. Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman are fantastic as the Owens sisters – it’s actually my favorite movie of hers! Everything about it, from the beautiful New England scenery and warm, candlelit homes to Stevie Nicks’ amazing music, just feels like autumn in a movie. It’s basically pumpkin spice latte in film form!

This movie perfectly captures the cozy feeling of classic romantic comedies, while also exploring themes of loss, the bond between sisters, and a hint of the mystical, all delivered with genuine emotion. The house featured in the film is as memorable as the magic itself—fans have been searching for its plans for years! It’s no surprise Practical Magic becomes popular online every autumn; it’s warm, charming, and heartfelt, offering a touch of magic without being scary. You’ll likely enjoy it even more than you remember, so it’s definitely worth watching.

Knives Out (2019)

If you enjoy a good mystery with your fall movies, Rian Johnson’s Knives Out is a perfect choice – it’s a thrilling, but not scary, whodunnit. Think of a classic Agatha Christie story updated for today, taking place in a large, atmospheric mansion in Massachusetts. The cozy fall vibes – with comfy sweaters, warm drinks, and rich wood details – make it a great movie to watch when the weather turns cold.

I have to say, Daniel Craig is fantastic as the detective, Ana de Armas is totally charming, and Chris Evans in that sweater? Iconic! But what I really love about Knives Out is how fun it is – it keeps you guessing, but it’s not actually frightening, and it’s smart without being too intense. It’s the ideal movie when you want something with a Halloween feel but still want to be able to relax. With two movies already out and another one, Wake Up Dead Man, coming soon, now is the perfect time to start watching the series and cozy up with these films this fall.

Fantastic Mr. Fox (2009)

I don’t usually love Wes Anderson’s films, but his stop-motion animation is fantastic. I think Fantastic Mr. Fox is a true gem – it’s like wrapping yourself in a comfortable, familiar sweater. The movie’s warm colors, folksy music, and gentle comedy make it perfect for autumn. Based on Roald Dahl’s classic children’s book, it tells the story of the witty Mr. Fox (voiced by George Clooney) and his attempts to trick three grumpy farmers.

The movie is visually stunning, packed with beautiful autumn details like golden leaves, cozy textures, and warm, inviting lights. It’s both heartwarming and funny, making it enjoyable for viewers of all ages. If you love fall and have a Pinterest board dedicated to the season, you’ll absolutely adore this film. In my opinion, it’s one of Wes Anderson’s finest works and deserves more recognition.

The Village (2004)

I firmly believe that M. Night Shyamalan’s The Village is among his strongest films. Even though some people focus on and are disappointed by the twist ending – which often impacts how his movies are received – it’s a truly enjoyable experience if you look past that. While it’s often called a thriller, The Village is more about creating a mood and atmosphere than being scary. The film’s beautiful autumn setting is particularly striking, and Bryce Dallas Howard gives a wonderful performance as the gentle character Ivy. James Newton Howard’s music also beautifully enhances the emotional impact of the story.

While there are some tense moments, this movie isn’t about startling jump scares. It’s a slow and reflective look at themes like fear, love, and the importance of community. If you enjoy fall-themed films with a slightly unsettling atmosphere and beautiful visuals, this movie delivers that cozy, autumnal feeling without being overly frightening.

Coco (2017)

Though set in Mexico, Pixar’s Coco shares the same heartwarming themes of family, memory, and tradition as classic fall movies. It beautifully celebrates Día de los Muertos (Day of the Dead) with a touching story about love and loss, gorgeous animation, and unforgettable music. Many consider it one of the best Latino films in years, guaranteed to make you both cry and sing along.

Miguel’s adventure in the Land of the Dead is heartwarming and full of life, not frightening. With its beautiful orange and yellow colors and deeply moving story, Coco perfectly captures the feeling of remembering and honoring ancestors. It’s a sweet reminder that family bonds, even those that last beyond our lifetimes, deserve to be cherished. This movie truly ranks among Pixar’s greatest achievements.

The Lake House (2006)

While it involves time travel, The Lake House is a surprisingly beautiful and often overlooked romantic film. It has a wistful, poetic feel, like a cozy autumn night. Starring Sandra Bullock and Keanu Reeves – who share a wonderfully subtle chemistry – the story centers on two people who fall in love by exchanging letters through a strange mailbox that connects them across time.

With its soft colors, thoughtful mood, and gradually unfolding story, this film feels perfectly suited for this time of year. It’s bittersweet and a little melancholy, but also strangely soothing – like revisiting a cherished memory or enjoying a beloved song from the past. It doesn’t aim to scare you, but instead offers a gentle emotional resonance and a subtle, cinematic magic.

When Harry Met Sally (1989)

If autumn were a romantic comedy, When Harry Met Sally would be it. The scenes of Meg Ryan and Billy Crystal strolling through Central Park in the fall are just as famous as any classic scary movie scene. It’s a warm, funny, and endlessly rewatchable film – who hasn’t quoted, “I’ll have what she’s having?” – making it the perfect cozy choice for those who prefer apple cider to spooky thrills.

Beyond its clever writing and the fantastic connection between the leads, When Harry Met Sally remains a classic because it feels genuinely real. It explores not just romance, but also the complexities of friendship, personal growth, and how important timing can be. The film portrays a relationship that starts with dislike, blossoms into a strong friendship, and then becomes something more – a type of story we don’t often see now, which is a shame. Its themes are universal and feel particularly comforting as autumn arrives, making it as essential to watch in October as wearing your favorite cozy flannel.

Final Thoughts On Cozy, Not Creepy

Fall has a unique charm, mixing feelings of nostalgia with the excitement of change and fresh starts. While scary movies are popular this time of year, they aren’t the only way to capture the autumn spirit. Films like Practical Magic, Knives Out, and The Lake House offer a different kind of enjoyment, reminding us that a cozy atmosphere can be just as captivating as a frightening one.

2025-10-25 00:10