Overhated & Underrated: The Wheel of Time was TV’s Most Overhated Masterpieces

by

Fantasy television is more popular than ever, which is fantastic! However, I was really disappointed when one of my favorite shows got canceled before its time. It was a wonderful series that beautifully adapted Robert Jordan’s work, and it just kept improving. It’s a shame it was cancelled due to a lot of unfair negativity.

Prime Video’s adaptation of The Wheel of Time premiered in 2021 and lasted for three seasons before being canceled, much to the disappointment of its fanbase. The show, featuring Rosamund Pike, Daniel Henney, and Josha Stradowski, had begun telling the story of Rand and the Dragon Reborn. While many believed The Wheel of Time had the potential to become a defining fantasy series for years to come, some viewers were overly critical of the changes made from the source material, creating a negative perception of the show.

The Wheel of Time Successfully Brought Robert Jordan’s World to Life

I absolutely loved the world built throughout his 14-book series. It’s a truly epic fantasy adventure, and I was so excited to finally see it adapted for television. Characters like Rand, Mat, and Egwene are among my favorites ever written, and they felt so real – they really deserved to be brought to life on screen.

Overall, the show did a good job bringing these beloved characters to life. It created a rich and detailed world that let viewers explore the complex story of the Dragon Reborn. The show’s strong visuals and excellent acting, from both new and established stars, made it even better.

From the very start, Rosamund Pike absolutely captivated me as Moiraine Damodred. She plays this incredibly complex character, an Aes Sedai – basically a powerful magic user – who’s spent her entire life searching for, and ultimately training, the Dragon Reborn. What I loved was how Pike managed to portray Moiraine as both distant and imposing, but also with this underlying sense of care and protectiveness. It was a really nuanced performance, and she totally nailed that delicate balance.

Rosamund Pike truly carried the show, and her performance was central to everything. She had a wonderful connection with Daniel Henney, who played her protector, Lan, and it seemed she naturally guided the other actors as well. As the series progressed, everyone benefited from her presence and delivered stronger performances.

The show was visually stunning, with incredibly creative designs for creatures like the Trollocs and Myrddraal, and a unique depiction of the One Power. These elements truly made the show stand out – the Trollocs felt original, and the magic system was unlike anything I’d seen before.

What truly made the show special was its consistent improvement with each season. It started with an 81% rating on Rotten Tomatoes for Season 1, then rose to 86% in Season 2, and reached a remarkable 97% with Season 3. The Wheel of Time consistently refined itself, delivering memorable scenes like the Battle of Falme and the Trial of Rhuidean.

It’s rare for a TV show to get better with each season – most shows decline in quality after the first. But Wheel of Time actually avoided that common problem. The show did such a great job that it reignited my love for Jordan’s world. Season 3 was incredible, and I was certain it would be the one to really launch the show to success, so I was completely stunned to hear it had been cancelled.

The Wheel of Time’s Issues Were Only Surface Deep

It’s important to acknowledge that The Wheel of Time wasn’t perfect. While the show stayed true to the feel of the original novels, it did make some changes to the plot and when things happened. I previously observed that the series was increasingly diverging from the books.

One reason the TV adaptation of The Wheel of Time differs from the books is the sheer size and complexity of the original story. While the books are amazing, faithfully recreating every detail on screen would likely make the pacing slow. It was a smart move to condense the timeline, though even I’ll admit some changes in the first season were hard to get used to. Despite those changes, the show consistently impressed me and successfully captured the spirit of the books.

Another significant problem with the show was its visual presentation – specifically, the costumes and set design. A believable world feels lived-in, with sets appearing worn and costumes reflecting the characters’ journeys through dirt and wear. However, The Wheel of Time, like many recent fantasy productions, often overlooks these important details.

The show often felt artificial and lacked a lived-in quality. Everything appeared too perfect – the towns were immaculate and the costumes were brand new – which made it hard to believe the characters actually inhabited this world, instead of just arriving on set for filming.

However, a lot of the criticism feels superficial. Sadly, these minor details are what some viewers who aren’t enjoying the show focus on. Even with strong acting, exciting action sequences, and the core essence of Rand al’Thor’s journey still present, these things were overshadowed by concerns about things like Rand arriving in Tar Valon at the ‘wrong’ time or wanting a clearer romantic storyline.

Despite any differences from the source material, the show successfully captured the most important parts of the story. The pivotal scenes from the books were brought to life on screen and remained exciting and enjoyable. It’s easy to focus on what’s changed in an adaptation, but it’s better to appreciate what works well.

Prime Video Killed The Wheel of Time at its Peak

Despite growing positive feedback and a dedicated audience, the show was cancelled due to financial concerns. Ultimately, the costs didn’t justify the number of viewers, and negative reactions played a significant role in the decision. It’s especially disappointing because the show was just starting to gain momentum.

I loved where The Wheel of Time was going after Season 3. I was really looking forward to seeing the Battle of Dumai Wells, Rand using Callandor, and Egwene with Vora’s sa’angreal. The show had built up so many exciting possibilities, and unfortunately, fans won’t get to experience them now.

As a huge fan of the books, it’s really disheartening to see how much negativity surrounds the show. Honestly, I’m worried all this hate will kill any chance of seeing future Wheel of Time adaptations. Amazon still owns the rights, and with so much backlash, they seem unlikely to invest in anything new. It feels like if people can’t embrace both the things they love and the changes that are made, we’re going to lose this world on screen for a long time, and that’s a real shame.

A promising start was unfortunately hindered by constant criticism. Despite steady progress and good performances, fans relentlessly complained whenever the adaptation deviated even slightly from the source material. This negativity was on top of the initial outrage some fans felt about the casting choices.

Disliking movies and shows doesn’t lead to positive outcomes. While canceling a series might feel like a win for some, it actually shows studios the franchise isn’t sustainable. Ultimately, it takes away enjoyment for fans without offering anything in return. The Wheel of Time was a unique series that will likely be forgotten for years, all because it faced unfair negativity.

Come back in 2 weeks when Nick Brooks tackles a controversial creature feature.

Read More

2026-01-01 20:15