Netflix’s price rise ruled “unlawful” and customers want refunds

A Rome court decided that Netflix illegally raised its prices in the past. This ruling could allow millions of users in Italy to request refunds, potentially receiving hundreds of euros each.

A recent court decision, issued on April 1st under case number 4993/2026, sided with the Italian consumer group Movimento Consumatori. The court ruled that Netflix’s terms allowing them to change subscription prices and contract details between 2017 and January 2024 were not legally valid.

Netflix plans to challenge the ruling and has announced it will file an appeal. The company emphasized that its customers are its priority and that it believes it has always followed Italian law and respected consumer rights.

Court rules Netflix price changes lacked justification

The court’s decision centers on Netflix’s use of a clause allowing it to change contract terms on its own—known as ‘ius variandi.’ Judges found that Netflix didn’t adequately explain in its contracts why prices might go up.

As a fan, I was really glad to hear the court’s decision! It basically said that just giving us a 30-day warning and a cancellation option wasn’t enough. They made it clear that companies should have told us exactly what could cause prices to change from the very beginning. It’s about being upfront and honest, which is what we all want!

Price increases for subscriptions in 2017, 2019, 2021, and November 2024, affecting contracts signed between 2017 and January 2024, have been ruled illegal. Customers will receive refunds for these increases.

The court also pointed out that Netflix’s terms of service, as updated in April 2025, are now acceptable. These new terms clearly connect any price increases to specific reasons like improvements to the service, changes in regulations, and the need for better security.

A recent decision is affecting millions of Netflix users in Italy, according to consumer group Movimento Consumatori. The number of people subscribing to the service in Italy has significantly increased, growing from 1.9 million in 2019 to approximately 5.4 million as of October 2025.

The group says that customers with premium plans were overcharged by a total of €8 per month, and those with standard plans by €4 per month. This means some long-term premium subscribers could get refunds of about €500, while standard plan users might receive around €250.

The court also requires Netflix to directly inform customers affected by the ruling. They must post the decision on their website for at least six months, send notifications to users by email or mail, and place announcements in prominent newspapers. Netflix has 90 days to fulfill these requirements, or they will be fined €700 each day they remain non-compliant.

As a consumer, I was really glad to hear Movimento Consumatori is demanding prices come down now that those unfair increases have been dealt with. They’re saying they’ll even take companies to court with a class action if people don’t get their money back, which is exactly what needs to happen!

Now, everything depends on Netflix’s upcoming appeal, where they will likely ask the court to temporarily stop enforcing the ruling.

Read More

2026-04-03 22:19