MLB The Show 26 Review – Grand Slam

by

Our review of MLB The Show 26 explores the newest installment in San Diego Studio’s popular baseball franchise. This year’s game features gameplay enhancements and several additions, including a more detailed Amateur Year mode, the World Baseball Classic in Diamond Dynasty, and fresh mechanics. But are these changes significant enough to make a difference? We’ll take a closer look to find out.

MLB The Show 26 Review – What is MLB The Show?

MLB The Show 26 is a baseball video game made by San Diego Studio and published by Sony Interactive Entertainment and MLB Advanced Media. The series has been around for over 20 years, starting with the first game in 2006. Before this, Sony published another baseball game series developed by 989 Sports, and MLB The Show 26 continues that legacy.

The game is available on PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S, and Nintendo Switch.

Gameplay – MLB The Show 26 Review

MLB The Show 26 plays much like previous versions, but features noticeable improvements to all aspects of the game, including pitching, hitting, and fielding.

One of the best things about the game is how customizable the gameplay is. It offers several different ways to hit and pitch, so players of all skill levels can find a style that suits them. I personally prefer the traditional pitching method, but you can also choose from options like pinpoint, meter, pulse, or a fully analog system.

And there’s more! Show 26 introduces a new feature called Bear Down Pitching that really changes the game, especially in important moments. It basically gives your next pitch a boost in speed and accuracy, making it easier to throw a perfect strike. You earn this ability through good performance as a pitcher – it’s tied to their Clutch Rating.

Bear Down Pitches introduce a smart new option when you’re trying to close out a game. While you could use them earlier, they’re really designed for high-pressure moments. For example, if you’re facing a tough hitter like Ronald Acuña Jr. with the bases loaded late in the game, a Bear Down Pitch might be a good choice.

Okay, so it’s not just the pitchers who’ve leveled up! As a player, I’ve got way more tools to check out past pitches now, which really helps me predict what’s coming next. And get this – there’s a new system where I can actually challenge the umpire’s calls on balls and strikes! It’s a game-changer, honestly.

I didn’t really need the automated ball-strike system (ABS) myself, but it’s good that it’s there for players. The umpire usually gets the calls right, so I’m not sure how often it will actually be necessary.

Players can now test out the new Big Zone Hitting feature. It lets you predict where the pitch will be and select that area, making it simpler than traditional zone hitting which demands very accurate timing. However, your player still needs to be a good hitter, and you won’t always pick the right spot.

Fixed Zone Hitting lets you focus your bat control on one area of the strike zone. I find this setting more comfortable and easier to use than Big Zone Hitting, especially because you can also adjust how sensitive the controls are, giving you more precise swing control.

I wasn’t a huge fan of some of the new features added this year. I like the Pop Time and pitching attributes, but I think the directional hitting attributes are a bit excessive.

It doesn’t ruin the game, but having just one setting for direction would have been sufficient. Honestly, that’s my only real issue with how it plays, and it’s a minor one. Everything else in MLB The Show 26 is fantastic.

The recent gameplay improvements benefit all game modes, including Franchise, Diamond Dynasty, and Storylines. So, how are those modes playing overall this year?

Storylines is back with a new season – its fourth – focusing on the Negro Leagues. If you’re new to MLB The Show, this series lets you experience the careers of legendary Negro Leagues players. You’ll play through key moments in their lives, complete challenges, and earn rewards as you go.

This year’s Storylines feature introduces the careers of four new baseball legends: Roy Campanella, Mamie “Peanut” Johnson, John Henry “Pop Lloyd,” and George “Mule” Suttles. Playing through the levels unlocks cool rewards like stadiums, uniforms, and bat skins. Plus, you can earn an 88 OVR James “Cool Papa” Bell card for your Diamond Dynasty team, giving you even more reason to play!

I enjoy reading this every year and hope to see even more stories in the future. It would be great if they added storylines for other players, like the Derek Jeter one they included in the latest version of the game.

Diamond Dynasty is back, and it’s been updated with some improvements. However, it wasn’t the mode I played the most. I’ve never really enjoyed collecting cards, although I understand why people do. I will say, though, that Diamond Dynasty doesn’t feel as pushy or demanding as similar modes in other games.

The game’s Seasonal XP Path is entirely free – there’s no paid option to get extra rewards. This is rare for modern sports games, as it lets all players earn cards through gameplay. While you can speed things up by buying in-game currency (Stubs) with real money to open more packs, the system is fair and acceptable, particularly compared to other games today.

I’m really impressed with how much content is available in Diamond Dynasty this year. With features like Conquest, Mini-Seasons, Player Programs, and the addition of the World Baseball Classic, it feels packed with things to do right from the start, which is great. Even though I haven’t always been a big Diamond Dynasty player myself, I really appreciate the way the SDS team has designed and updated the mode.

I actually enjoy playing both Franchise mode and Road to the Show. We’ll discuss Road to the Show shortly, but let’s start by talking about Franchise mode.

This year, the biggest upgrades have been the additional trade slot and the new trade hub. These changes give you much more control over your trades and provide better information about what you’re buying and selling.

The game’s trading system and the AI of opposing managers have both been updated. While these kinds of improvements happen frequently, it’s good to see the developers continuing to refine how the game works under the hood.

The game’s team setups and player rotations are now more realistic and intelligent. While I didn’t have enough time with the Franchise mode to fully experience these changes, it’s still a welcome improvement.

The biggest update to Franchise mode is the new Streamlined experience, which replaces March to October. It offers similar functionality to March to October, but gives you more control. You can now customize how many games you play and choose exactly when you want to take over team management.

If you want an easier setup, Streamlined mode is a good option. However, I suggest trying Full Control – it lets you manage multiple teams and customize your league to a greater extent.

Franchise mode is still really fun to play. It feels like the developers focused more on Road to the Show and Diamond Dynasty this year, but thankfully Franchise received some attention too. Many players will happily spend countless hours immersed in Franchise, as each playthrough offers a unique experience.

Okay, so I’ve been playing MLB The Show 26, and honestly, the gameplay is still top-notch. It’s easy to pick up if you’re new to baseball games, but there’s a ton of depth if you’re a seasoned player like me. I’m already sinking hours into all the different modes, and it feels like there’s endless replayability. Plus, the developers are promising even more content throughout the season with updates and stuff for Diamond Dynasty, so it’s looking like a game I’ll be playing for a long time!

Story (Road To The Show) – MLB The Show 26 Review

Road to the Show is the main attraction in MLB The Show 26. This career mode lets you create a player and guide them through their entire baseball journey, from high school or college all the way to retirement. Last year, the game added the ability to play college baseball, giving you more options for starting your career.

This year’s version of the game really expands on the college baseball experience, featuring a wider range of schools to choose from. Along with returning favorites like LSU and Texas, players can now start their careers at schools such as North Carolina, Clemson, and Florida – bringing the total to 19 different college programs. If you prefer, you can still skip college and go straight to the draft and minor leagues.

I really appreciate how much freedom you have to shape your game, even before becoming a professional. With so many colleges to choose from, unique bonuses available, and the ability to enter the draft immediately, the early years of the game feel like a complete experience on their own.

Adding the NCAA Men’s College World Series was a fantastic addition. It makes the amateur experience more complete and extends the fun of playing during your younger years.

One of the best things about this game is how many different positions you can have your player cover. I made a character who could play pitcher, designated hitter, and shortstop – I was aiming for a combination of Shohei Ohtani’s pitching and hitting ability with the fielding skills of Derek Jeter, which means I can use him in a lot of different situations.

Unlike many sports games that restrict you to one or two positions, Road To The Show lets you play as much or as little as you prefer. I found a great balance that worked for me, and I think other players will too. Plus, you can easily switch positions if you want to try something different.

As a player, I really appreciate how much control the game gives you, even at the pro level. Things like requesting trades or managing my contract feel really polished and easy to use. Plus, you can actually make moves during the season that can change your career path. It’s cool because you’re never stuck – I can always try playing a different position or even sign with a new team if I want to.

You can also set goals for yourself, from small achievements like getting a specific number of strikeouts to larger ones like winning a season prize. As you reach these goals, you’ll earn Perks that make your character stronger, but in a way that feels natural and avoids overly simplistic gameplay.

Similar to the Franchise mode, you can choose to simulate games in this mode. I really like that the developers included a notification system to let you know when important moments are happening. I don’t usually simulate games, but it’s great to know the game will alert you before a key play if you do need to speed things up.

As a huge fan, I still think Road to the Show is one of the best career modes in any video game ever. It’s just so much fun to play again and again, and I love how much control I have over my player’s journey. That’s why it’s always been my favorite part of The Show, and this year’s updates have made it even better – it really delivers everything I want from a career mode!

If RTTS is your favorite mode, you won’t be disappointed this year.

Graphics & Presentation  – MLB The Show 26 Review

MLB The Show 26 doesn’t look much different from last year’s version, and honestly, I didn’t notice a significant improvement in the graphics. But I don’t usually focus on graphics when I’m evaluating a game, and I understand it’s tough to make huge visual leaps every single year with an annual release.

Overall, MLB The Show 26 looks good in the areas that matter most. The stadiums, uniforms, and equipment all appear solid. While the player models could be slightly improved, it’s still easy to identify players. I appreciate that the developers prioritized gameplay and game modes over making major visual upgrades.

Overall, the graphics in The Show 26 are decent – not amazing, but perfectly acceptable. I wasn’t expecting top-of-the-line visuals, and the face scanning for the Road to the Show mode works surprisingly well. Considering the development time and the focus on gameplay and modes, the graphics are solid.

MLB The Show 26 really shines with how it looks. It beautifully captures the history of baseball, from the classic uniforms and stadiums of the Negro Leagues to the modern designs used in the World Baseball Classic, celebrating the sport’s entire legacy.

College Stadiums have clearly improved! I experienced this firsthand with exciting new cheers, unique team traditions, and attending the Men’s College World Series.

Audio – MLB The Show 26 Review

While The Show 26 might not be visually stunning, it really excels with its audio quality.

Even now, The Show has the best commentary of any sports game available. Jon “Boog” Sciambi and Chris “Singy” Singleton deliver realistic and engaging conversations that often sound just like a real Major League Baseball broadcast – I even laughed out loud a few times!

The game’s audio is generally good, with realistic player conversations and satisfying sound effects, like when the bat connects with the ball. It also features a pleasant soundtrack that enhances the experience without being distracting.

Verdict: Is MLB The Show 26 Worth Your Time & Money?

MLB The Show 26 is a home run for the series! San Diego Studio has once again delivered the best baseball video game experience with its engaging gameplay, compelling career mode, and plenty of content available right from the start.

San Diego Studio continues to refine how The Show plays, all while staying true to what makes it enjoyable. Unlike many other sports games, The Show focuses on delivering fun gameplay rather than flashy graphics or expensive add-ons.

I still think Road to the Show is one of the best ways to experience a baseball career in a game. They’ve really made the college/amateur part better, and honestly, it’s so fun I want to start multiple playthroughs just to check out all the different schools!

Even though I don’t play Diamond Dynasty very often, I’m really impressed with how much content is available right from the start. It’s fantastic that you can earn everything in the game without spending any real money! You can buy in-game currency if you want, but there aren’t any paywalls or systems pushing you to spend extra. San Diego Studio deserves a lot of credit for creating a fair and balanced experience.

Okay, so the Franchise mode didn’t get all the attention it deserved, but honestly, it’s still really fun. What I like is that you can choose to play it super relaxed and let the game handle a lot, or really dive in and control everything yourself. That flexibility is awesome and lets you play it exactly how you want.

What really sets The Show 26 apart is its incredible depth of customization. Beyond the excellent gameplay, you can tweak almost everything to perfectly match your playstyle – something no other sports game lets you do to this extent. It’s this level of control that makes it a strong candidate for sports game of the year, and SDS has once again delivered a fantastic experience.

Whether you’re new to the series or a returning fan, I highly recommend checking this one out.

Score: 9.5/10

Read More

2026-03-17 23:43