Is a Major Rework for Farming Coming to Manor Lords? Players Weigh In!

by

Explore the intriguing strategy game, Manor Lords, where you embark on a journey into the heart of the medieval era, overseeing aspects from village life to battles. Yet, as gamers delve deeper into this immersive experience, certain difficulties are arising, predominantly in the farming aspect. A recent post by Alstroph on the game’s subreddit has brought these challenges to light, likening farm workforce management to trying to control a group of cats on a rainy day. The ensuing discussions revealed widespread dissatisfaction among players who believe that the farming system urgently requires an upgrade, expressing their concerns about its current state. Join us as we delve into these sentiments and uncover what players have to say about the farming mechanics in the game.

Summary

  • A significant portion of players find the current farming mechanics cumbersome and in need of a major rework.
  • Suggestions from the community include the implementation of automatic job assignment and a more efficient workflow for farmers.
  • Some players report enjoying the farming system, arguing that they’ve found ways to optimize their strategies.
  • The divide in player experience highlights the need for balance in game mechanics to cater to different play styles.

Current Farming Woes

As a Manor Lords player, I’m finding myself increasingly frustrated with the farming mechanics in the game. A post by Alstroph seems to have sparked a discussion about this very issue. It appears that the tedium of reallocating my workforce during the changing seasons is causing most of the distress. In spring, I spend hours assigning families to tend the fields, only to have to do an about-face in winter. Alstroph expressed his exasperation over having more oxen than available crop plots, saying “Why are only 3 of my 4 oxen working though?” This sentiment echoes throughout the community, with many players feeling that the system requires a constant balancing act, which can quickly become exhausting and lead to burnout. One user put it succinctly when they said, “the farm game loop is one of the most frustrating parts of this game.” Honestly, the current state of the game leaves me feeling overwhelmed rather than engaged, making me question if farming is even worth the hassle.

Community Suggestions for Improvement

In response to their frustrations, community members are brainstorming creative ideas. One popular concept is implementing an automatic job assignment system for workers who become inactive during winter. Samuele156 suggests that farmers who can’t work could be given alternative roles as builders or other essential jobs, improving the overall workflow. This would keep them occupied instead of idling during off-seasons. Additionally, there are proposals for a ‘second job’ system that lets players assign additional tasks to their workers during downtime. Angry_worder brought up an intriguing point about finding the right balance between micromanagement and automation, suggesting alarms for players to remind them when to reassign farmers. If implemented, these changes could improve gameplay and address some of the current farming challenges.

Mixed Experiences in Farming

It’s interesting to note that while some players are expressing concerns about the farming mechanics, others seem to be thriving without any issues. For instance, minnow87 declared that he finds it simple enough to set his farmers to tasks and then forget about them, suggesting a strategy that apparently helps him avoid the widespread frustrations. Similarly, Mr_Reaper__ has offered useful tips on reassigned workers during harvest periods, stating that he prefers to line up laborers from different sources before winter arrives. This approach seems to be effective for him, as he describes an efficient cycle of task assignment and switching that maintains productivity throughout the year. The diverse experiences of players hint at the mechanics accommodating various playstyles, thus opening up a more extensive conversation about the game’s balance requirements and potentially the need for comprehensive tutorials for new users.

Balancing the Experience

One of the main issues discussed in these posts is striking a balance between automated and hands-on farming in the game. Some players enjoy the challenge of assigning tasks and managing their virtual villages, finding satisfaction in this level of control. However, others find it overwhelming to constantly reassign workers, leading to frustration. The desire among many users is for a system that allows both interaction and an easier, more intuitive approach to farming. A potential solution could be a system that lets players automate certain processes while still providing the option for manual assignment, catering to both types of players and enhancing overall game enjoyment.

In a strategy game, a flourishing village should offer a sense of accomplishment, but repeated difficulties can make even devoted gamers yearn for a rest. The discussions about farming in Manor Lords show that the community yearns for an overhaul of its mechanics. As players suggest creative solutions and share their distinct stories, the game creators have the chance to listen and modify. This could involve automated tasks, improved seasonal planning, or striking a balance between management and automation. The farming system’s development remains uncertain, but one thing is clear: players are passionate about their virtual farms, and they aren’t shy about expressing their grievances during the journey.

Read More

2025-01-27 04:28