Gaming News: Elden Ring Shadow of the Erdtree DLC Excluded from BAFTA Best Game Award

As someone who’s spent countless hours immersed in the vast world of Elden Ring and its captivating lore, I find myself intrigued by this ongoing debate about its DLC not being eligible for BAFTA’s Best Game award.

Gaming News is lighting up with discussions around the recently announced decision that Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree DLC will not be eligible for the BAFTA’s Best Game award. The post by user Turbostrider27 has sparked a lively debate among fans and gamers alike. The discussion revolves around the reasoning behind the exclusion and whether expansions deserve a place at the prestigious award table alongside standalone games. As the fervor continues, opinions from both sides are pouring in, shedding light on gamer perspectives regarding game awards and categories.

Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree DLC won’t be eligible for BAFTA’s Best Game award
byu/Turbostrider27 inGames

Summary

The decision to exclude the Elden Ring DLC from the Best Game award has ignited passionate discussions among fans.
Many believe expansions should compete separately, as they aren’t standalone products.
Some users express dissatisfaction with the BAFTA award process, arguing it lacks fairness.
Overall sentiment appears to favor the exclusion, with many supporting the decision.

Opinions on Exclusion

The overall sentiment in the comments of the Reddit post leans heavily towards the acceptance of BAFTA’s decision to exclude the Elden Ring DLC from the Best Game category. User timasahh argues, “Good in my opinion. I know it’s pedantic but regardless of quality, it’s not its own game.” This sentiment resonates throughout the thread as many believe that expansions are better suited for other categories, such as Best Expansion or Best Continued Support. It seems a general sense of fairness drives these opinions; awards for standalone games should represent new offerings rather than add-ons to existing experiences.

Arguments for Inclusion

Some users aren’t entirely convinced about the decision. Pioneer83 argues, “If a game can be played independently without requiring another game, it should qualify for Game of the Year.” This view suggests that the Elden Ring DLC has enough unique content and gameplay elements to warrant recognition, as it can function independently. These users believe that the award system ought to be broader, particularly when expansions significantly enhance gameplay experiences and storylines.

The Role of Expansions in Gaming

As a gaming enthusiast, I strongly believe that expansions play a significant role in the gaming world, but they’re not always seen as separate entities with their own merit. Visk-235W puts it simply: “It’s not a new game; it’s an expansion for a game released in 2022.” This sentiment echoes a common view that expansions often need the base game to be relevant and engaging, which might explain why they sometimes get overlooked in major award categories. It seems crucial to gamers to preserve the distinction between standalone games and expansions, acknowledging and appreciating the original titles that continue to thrive independently.

Questioning the Award Process

Additionally, users such as greyhoodbry express doubts about the BAFTA award process, expressing their viewpoint that “It often seems like it’s eligible because it’s incredibly good,” which encapsulates the criticism leveled at the system for unclear eligibility criteria, concerns over fairness, and disregard for the presented body of work each year. The possibility that both Elden Ring and its expansion may have been nominated stirs dissatisfaction among users, who feel it confuses what the awards should commend.

Adding Humor to the Debate

Some participants injected a touch of humor into their discussions, like BeardFalcon who pretended to be puzzled by saying, “What exactly is the North American Free Trade Agreement?” This friendly banter highlights the more casual aspect of the conversation, despite its serious undertones. It underscores that even in debates with strong opinions, gamers frequently appreciate humor in outrageous comparisons, adding a bit of fun to the otherwise intense discussion about industry recognition.

Final Thoughts on Awards in Gaming

As these talks progress, they reveal the fervent spirit and intricate views of the gaming community about the award systems currently in use. The controversy surrounding BAFTA’s decision not to include Elden Ring DLC in the Best Game category serves as a prime example of how games are classified and acknowledged. Gamers eagerly participate in these debates, expressing their thoughts and contributing layers of wit, exasperation, and justice to the discourse, thereby demonstrating the diverse array of opinions that abound within the community.

2024-12-10 21:43