Are We Doomed?

As a long-time comic book enthusiast and moviegoer, I must say that the prospect of Downey joining the Marvel Universe as Doctor Doom is nothing short of exhilarating! Having grown up with Tony Stark and Victor Von Doom’s rivalry on the pages of my favorite comics, seeing these two iconic characters share the screen for real is a dream come true.


Victor Von Doom resides in the gloomy and gothic nation of Latveria, nestled within Europe’s misty mountains. He is a ruthless ruler with ambitions for world conquest, a mad scientist whose experiments have left him scarred, and an evil sorcerer with demonic associates. He bears the same name as Frankenstein and dwells in a castle reminiscent of Dracula’s. In political terms, he resembles Putin Rasputin. However, his image does not align with Robert Downey Jr.

Over the course of ten Marvel films spanning eleven years, Downey Jr. portrayed Iron Man as a witty, intelligent character. The term “suave dork” might seem contradictory, but it’s the best way to describe the alluring charisma of Tony Stark’s unconventional beard. Downey brought to life two improbable fantasies: a tech CEO who was indeed as smart as he appeared to be and a wealthy individual who seemed (but wasn’t) under the influence of cocaine. This was quite unexpected in 2008, when the most favored screen superheroes were sad X-Men characters, an angry young Batman, and a crying Spiderman. The most surprising aspect of Iron Man was that the scenes involving the metal suit were somewhat underwhelming. Instead, it was Downey’s dialogue scenes that proved to be more entertaining.

The actor has demonstrated his ability to play villainous roles effectively, as shown by his Oscar-winning portrayal of grumpy military-industrial bureaucracy in “Oppenheimer.” However, I find myself preferring him in “U.S. Marshals,” where he masterfully portrayed a deceitful young Downey betraying a stern Tommy Lee Jones. Despite this, there’s a part of me that questions whether his energetic, improvisational Iron Man persona suits the brooding and despotic sorcerer character of Victor Von Doom. Von Doom is foreign, tragic, mysterious, ruling with an iron fist, coveting immense power that could be his downfall, and struggling with complex family issues.

After experiencing a few tough years with disappointing box office returns, the Marvel Cinematic Universe is trying to revitalize itself by teaming up its founding star with Anthony and Joe Russo, directors of some of the franchise’s most successful films. Despite their success in the past, they haven’t made much impact with their post-“Avengers” projects. Marvel is aiming to recapture its former glory. As for Downey, it seems he’s motivated by financial gain (specifically a substantial amount). However, let’s consider a top-tier actor who has already amassed a significant fortune during his first decade with Marvel. What could have drawn him back to this new role? We might speculate that he found a creative incentive beyond the monetary rewards.

Let’s first identify what we already know about Victor Von Doom’s role in the upcoming Avengers film. At San Diego Comic-Con, Joe Russo referred to Robert Downey Jr. as “the one person who could play Victor Von Doom.” Given that no one ever lies during a press conference, it is unlikely that Downey will reappear in the MCU as an alternate reality Stark or the resurrected original Tony Stark. The multiverse offers endless possibilities, but having multiple characters with the same appearance could make the storyline confusing and strange, especially if our new villain looks exactly like Earth’s mightiest hero.

It’s not uncommon in stories, like those from Marvel comics, to find characters who initially appear good turning out to be evil or vice versa. For instance, we’ve seen both evil Iron Men and kind-hearted alternate reality Dooms. This pattern of character transformation leads me to wonder if there’s some hidden aspect to Downey’s casting that we haven’t discovered yet. Could it be clones, twins, or perhaps a connection between his current and future Marvel roles? Even his recent Instagram post, “New Mask, same task,” suggests a shared element between them.

It’s clear that I’m combing through Downey’s Instagram posts in search of hints, which suggests that the stunt casting has effectively generated buzz and served as a public relations makeover. Marvel’s ambitious plan to focus on Jonathan Majors’ Kang in the 2020s encountered obstacles, both legal and financial, with the unimpressive box office performance of his first major film appearance in “Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania“. Had they chosen any up-and-coming actor like Jacob Elordi, Austin Butler, or Paul Mescal for Doom, we would be left speculating about their talent until the following two years. In contrast, Downey offers a blend of familiarity, enigma, nostalgia, and transformation. He’s returned, but to what end?

Admit it, visualizing any actor embodying the character is quite a challenge. Jack Kirby, a legendary artist, crafted Doctor Doom’s stunning costume as an intriguing blend of robotic armor and medieval wizardly attire that seems extraordinary on paper but, let’s be honest, a bit comical when worn by real humans. I mean, the green robe falls just above the knee, making it appear like he’s wearing a miniskirt in some panels where Doctor Doom appears! The techno-magic aesthetic is tricky to nail, and most filmmakers shy away from attempting it. Unfortunately, Julian McMahon didn’t quite pull off the role in 2005’s Fantastic Four, and Toby Kebbell seemed even less convincing in 2015’s The Fantastic Four.

The two failed franchises primarily centered on Doom’s rivalry with his former friend Reed Richards, while glossing over the extravagant elements of his mythology such as his private kingdom, his witch mother, and robot doubles. They didn’t explore his Romani heritage, a background that has sparked whitewashing concerns among some critics. Additionally, they never hinted at Doom possibly being related to Kang, a connection introduced by Marvel co-creator Stan Lee in the 1960s comics. Although this family link is unclear, some cynics view Downey’s casting as a replacement of one time-traveling tyrant with another, with Downey set to assume roles that Majors might have played in future Avengers films.

As a follower, I can see potential for enhancements in the portrayal of Majors’ characters in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. In his initial appearance as Loki and the Quantumania storyline, he was tasked with embodying an ancient entity living beyond conventional space-time definitions, often reliant on green screen and lacking a clear driving force other than Cosmic Control. It’s exciting to speculate that Downey’s portrayal of Doom might be more grounded in a specific setting and offer a stronger character dynamic. Unfortunately, it remains uncertain if Doom will appear in Fantastic Four: First Steps, but with Pedro Pascal stepping into the Mr. Fantastic role, future Marvel crossovers could revisit the Reed-Doom relationship, similar to how the first Avengers used Loki’s specific rivalry with Thor as a foundation for his confrontation against the team.

In the realm of cinema criticism, I must say that the 2027 blockbuster, Avengers: Secret Wars, bears a striking resemblance to the comic book series of the same name from the 2010s. In this tale, the mastermind Doctor Doom manages to merge all realities into a singular planet. While the specifics may vary on the silver screen, it’s safe to assume that a similar event will unfold given Marvel’s penchant for intertwining multiple versions of characters within their narratives, as exemplified by pairings such as Deadpool & Wolverine, Loki, and the latest iterations of Spider-Men.

As a cinema enthusiast, I’m speculating that we might see Robert Downey Jr.’s portrayal of Doom intertwined with this cinematic universe through one of his favorite gadgets: the Time Platform. This device was initially introduced by the villain in 1962, when he manipulated the Fantastic Four into traveling back to the past for a treasure hunt (can’t help but miss those simpler times!). Picture the time-bending thrills of Avengers: Endgame combined with the interdimensional escapades of Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, Downey slipping into the role of Doom across scenes from a whopping 34 films!

As a die-hard comic book fan, I’ve often pondered: Will Downey ever meet Downey? The interaction between Doctor Doom and Iron Man has been scarce in the comics world. Over the vast expanse of comic time and countless crossovers, there exists at least one version where Tony Stark donned the mantle of Doctor Doom, and another in which Victor Von Doom stood as an ally to Stark. In the 80s, a few seminal storylines featured them together in tales that twisted through time travel, even bringing them alongside the Knights of the Round Table.

It appears rather improbable that several masked Downeys would engage in sword fights with King Arthur and Blackbeard the pirate. However, the most intriguing scenarios might just be the oddest ones. With his recent roles in Oppenheimer and The Sympathizer, for which he received an Emmy nomination, Downey has been subtly distancing himself from his Tony Stark character, using makeup, intricate wigs, and various voices to hide. If this trend continues, Doctor Doom could be a similar exploration. Imagine Downey with a thick European accent, flourishing his green cape dramatically.

The initial success of the actor in the movie ‘Iron Man’ was largely due to his ability to subtly poke fun at the seriousness associated with superheroes. Could he flip this role into a more villainous character, intensifying his wickedness to an almost Shakespearean level, which typically goes against Marvel’s light-hearted and self-referential style? It seems that Downey is rejoining a group of characters that were once the stars but have now been replaced by younger actors, non-iconic figures like Moon Knight, and far too many Ant-people. The success of Deadpool and Wolverine’s violent, meta-referential style lies in its departure from traditional Disney-approved Marvel themes, even as it incorporates cameos that nostalgically remind us of earlier Marvel versions. Placing Downey at the center of a massive crossover event is a more daring move towards revisiting the past. I hope his performance will be unique and deeply rooted in the character’s complex history. If he merely becomes another multiverse villain, playing multiple versions of himself in a generic headquarters where clips from previous MCU films are played on viewscreens, then we might be in trouble.

Read More

2024-07-31 23:54