Almost 40 Years Ago, We Got A Perfectly Timely (And Timeless) Christmas Carol Riff

by

Scrooged is just one of many movies inspired by Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol, but it remains a classic. Directed by Richard Donner, the film is a playful take on the beloved story and marked Bill Murray’s return to leading roles after his hit movie, Ghostbusters.

Starring Karen Allen, Alfre Woodard, John Glover, John Forsythe, and Carol Kane, the film Scrooged initially received mixed reactions from critics. Over time, however, it’s become a beloved holiday tradition with a loyal following. Its lasting appeal lies in its clever, sometimes biting, 1980s humor combined with a classic retelling of the familiar story.

Scrooged Is The Most 1980s Christmas Carol Ever

What makes Scrooged a truly great take on A Christmas Carol is its surprising blend of darkness, sharp wit, and genuine heart. Bill Murray delivers a standout performance as Frank Cross, a TV executive who’s selfish, mean-spirited, and quick to anger – a role that takes his usual comedic style to a new level.

Bill Murray is perfectly suited for this role because he can play the character’s wild behavior for comedic effect, but also subtly reveal the character’s hidden anger and surprising moments of weakness. Like a modern-day Scrooge, the character is a businessman who gains power by controlling what entertainment people enjoy.

Cross went to great lengths to get as many viewers as possible for his network’s version of A Christmas Carol, and ironically, this caused an elderly woman to have a heart attack – which he then happily used as a publicity win. This callous disregard for others aligns with how Scrooge is often depicted in the story.

The film is strongly and intentionally set in the 1980s, filled with references to the 1950s. It explores themes of increasing wealth inequality and presents a bleak view of American society. A scene involving a shooting attempt feels particularly impactful and relevant in today’s world, especially when compared to the original film, Scrooged.

The movie Scrooged is firmly rooted in the 1980s, with details like references to the Berlin Wall and VCRs being considered high-end gifts. It also explores serious themes, such as the emotional trauma experienced by the character Calvin Cooley, who is unable to speak after a personal tragedy. What makes this version particularly effective is its gritty, realistic depiction of city life—a stark contrast to many other adaptations of the classic story.

The comedy in Scrooged is sharp and reflects the gritty side of the 1980s. While the film updates classic characters like Scrooge, Cratchit, and Jacob Marley to fit the time period, it also emphasizes what makes these characters universally relatable and enduring.

Scrooged Is A Harsh Satire And A Sweet Story

I watch Scrooged every year – it’s one of my favorite adaptations of A Christmas Carol. What I especially love is how the film balances its darker, grittier moments with a really hopeful and human story. Bill Murray’s Scrooge is particularly harsh, and he actively fights against the lessons he’s being shown.

Perhaps the most emotionally powerful scene in the movie occurs when Cross, after leaving a ghostly vision, discovers the frozen body of a man he previously met at a shelter. He becomes furious, questioning why the man didn’t seek help, which sharply contradicts Cross’s own belief that people in need should be ignored.

He isn’t someone who easily learns from his mistakes. Cross points out that Scrooge is a brilliantly written character because he’s initially awful and self-centered, only changing when he’s forced to face the consequences of his actions. This makes Cross’s own transformation—desperately pleading for help to avoid his fate—especially impactful.

Ebenezer Scrooge is a miser who needs to change his ways. He initially tries to rationalize the ghostly visions he experiences, then attempts to negotiate, and ultimately reluctantly acknowledges their meaning. But nothing stops the ghosts until he’s desperately pleading for one more opportunity. The film Scrooged then surprisingly blends sincere emotion with dark humor, creating a uniquely impactful and memorable story.

Scrooged is a humorous and sometimes tough movie, but ultimately it’s comforting, like many great holiday stories. The film concludes with Cross truly apologizing for his mistakes, connecting with his family, and encouraging others to do the same. It’s a genuinely heartwarming Christmas transformation, especially for a character who mirrors Tiny Tim, and it feels completely earned.

My family always watches “Scrooged” during the holidays. Its darkly funny take on things actually makes the best parts of the season feel even more special. The movie ends with a powerful song that crosses the boundary between life and death. It’s a fantastic and unique take on the classic “Christmas Carol” story – both relevant to today and eternally heartwarming.

Read More

2025-12-09 05:19