‘About a Hero’ Review: An AI-Assisted Docu-Mystery That Won’t Give Werner Herzog Any Sleepless Nights

As a seasoned cinephile and technology enthusiast with over three decades of experience under my belt, I must say that “About a Hero” left me with a peculiar sense of discombobulation. The film’s audacious experimentation with AI-driven storytelling is undeniably intriguing, but it falls short in delivering a coherent narrative or compelling argument about the implications of artificial intelligence for humanity.


The movie “About a Hero” encourages viewers to maintain a degree of skepticism while watching, unlike most films that ask for suspension of disbelief. This film, directed by Polish filmmaker Piotr Winiewicz, uses AI in its storytelling and has a disclaimer advising caution regarding its visual and auditory elements. This unconventional documentary, which some might not even categorize as a documentary, combines an imaginary murder mystery with discussions on artificial intelligence. However, the movie doesn’t provide any clear distinction between what’s real or fictitious, making it challenging for viewers to trust its content. While it has some cleverness in its approach, it lacks substantial ideas and arguments.

Despite the impressive use of innovative techniques and renowned collaborations in “About a Hero”, the film may capture the attention of distributors as it travels through the documentary festival circuit, even if one of the most famous contributors isn’t physically involved. Instead, an AI model has been trained on Werner Herzog‘s filmography to create a story about an unexplained death in a German town and to mimic Herzog’s voice for narration. The AI character is named Kaspar Hauser, and while it comes close to authenticity, it’s slightly off in various details, such as its deepfake imitation of Herzog’s distinctive voice, which is more reminiscent of a party trick than a convincing impression.

The movie, titled “About a Hero,” seems to embrace its peculiarities rather than being a promotion for AI. It subtly defies Herzog’s skepticism while simultaneously validating it. As the story – not entirely original but molded from the AI model’s responses by Winiewicz – becomes increasingly chaotic, it might work better as a catalyst for discussions, either in a festival setting or following a screening, rather than standing alone effectively.

The narrative, structured without a clear numerical sequence, revolves around an enigmatic character: Dorem Clery, a seemingly ordinary worker at a fictional German town’s kitchen appliance factory called Getunkirchenberg. Clery meets an untimely end under mysterious circumstances that remain ambiguous, whether due to suspicious activities or a plot twist in the AI-driven narrative. It is later revealed that Clery was working on a mysterious project known as “the Machine,” representing advancements in AI technology and potentially connected to his demise. The film delves into this angle but often diverts, focusing instead on Eleonore (portrayed by Imme Beccard), the widow of Clery. As she grapples with her grief, Eleonore’s interactions with household appliances evolve into a very literal manifestation of technophilia.

If you find it understandable, definitive, and engaging in your mind, it seems you might be losing touch with reality, says Herzog, as Eleonore gets playful with a toaster – an event not uncommon in this film that frequently acknowledges its intentional imperfections for comic effect. The humor can become repetitive towards the end. It’s more effective when Winiewicz allows viewers to discover the flaws on their own, such as the recurring misspellings of “police” throughout the procedural segments. Regarding the documentary aspect, the interviewees – including Stephen Fry and cultural critic Charles Mudede – provide insightful but ambiguous thoughts on AI, contributing little to solidifying or shaping the film’s hazy premise. Eight years ago, Herzog’s documentary “Lo and Behold, Reveries of the Connected World” offered a more substantial exploration of humanity’s impending conflict with its own digital advancements, but with significantly less self-referential trickery.

Mudede expresses his openness to questioning the notion that humans hold exclusive intelligence. However, “About a Hero” doesn’t delve deeply into artificial intelligence as a form of post-human intelligence. The filmmakers’ handling of AI technology in the movie is controlled and moderated, whether for reasons of reason, irony, or entertainment. This human touch makes the film more appealing to watch, as it boasts excellent cinematography and design, with Vicky Krieps delivering a witty performance as a stressed reporter investigating the Clery case. If it’s meant to provoke thought, it does so in a subtle, cautious way, possibly serving as a comforting reminder that our current understanding of life and art may persist for some time, if not forever.

Read More

2024-11-17 14:46