Outlander Recap: Introducing the Lady Grey

by

As a historian with a penchant for the turbulent times of the American Revolution, I must say that this latest episode was as thrilling as it was heart-wrenching. The lives of these characters are a constant rollercoaster ride, and it’s hard not to become emotionally invested in their stories.

Friends who love Outlander, I had a hearty chuckle during “A Hundredweight of Stone”. It seems that despite seven seasons packed with gruesome scenes, graphic violence, and sorrowful episodes, the creators have now drawn a line they won’t cross – Claire Fraser and Lord John Grey sharing a scene of grief-stricken intimacy?! I find it amusing to think that the powers that be deemed this scene too intense for viewers to handle! They decided to portray the lead-up to the intimate moment as quick cuts before fading to black, then transitioning to them waking up together awkwardly. It’s almost comical to me that they believe audiences can endure everything else but not this. Honestly, there are numerous scenes in Outlander I wish I could erase from my memory, and this one wouldn’t even make the list! Nonetheless, it was quite a laughable decision.

Here’s one way to rephrase that paragraph: Instead of implying I’m unexpectedly rooting for Claire and Lord John, if Outlander decides to pursue this plotline (which seems rather implausible), it should stick with the decision. With the time constraints due to the spy accusations, I find it hard to believe that Claire wouldn’t verify her husband’s death by writing a letter. The story is rushing through essential moments, but it keeps focusing on Roger, who this week acquires a gemstone for future stone travel and discovers his father’s Royal Air Force jacket. These scenes between Roger and Buck feel like they could have been emails instead of actual interactions. However, there are far more intriguing developments taking place in 1778. In fact, we also have more engaging storylines happening in 1980 where — surprise! — Rob Cameron did not transport Jemmy through the stones; he merely intended to get rid of Roger. Bree is still unaware of her son’s whereabouts, but she does attack Rob with a frying pan, which is quite exciting.

It’s disappointing that the Claire/Lord John situation isn’t getting more attention or development. The complexities of their marriage, encounters, and shared grief are crucial elements in one of TV’s most intricate love triangles on ‘Outlander’. This is especially frustrating because Caitriona Balfe and David Berry have consistently demonstrated their ability to bring depth to the relationship between Claire and Lord John. It’s a shame that we don’t get more episodes dedicated to exploring their evolving dynamic, as it would add depth to the story when Jamie returns in Philadelphia. Although it’s expected that chaos will ensue once Jamie discovers what Claire and his friend have been doing while he was away, a deeper exploration of their new relationship would have enriched the series.

Please note: I’m complaining out of love! What we do get of this duo is so good! It’s such an interesting look at how this pair are dealing with their grief both separately and as a pair: Claire, a zombie person; John, beside himself, pouring his sadness into his mission to keep Jamie’s wife safe. When William can’t understand why his father would risk his reputation and marry a rebel, why he would go to bat so hard for this other man who was just a groom and now a traitor, John has to work so hard not to blurt out first because Jamie is the love of his life and second because Jamie is your real father and you are my greatest joy; What two insane secrets to keep! The tears in that man’s eyes! The moment when he looks over at the empty chair across from his chess board, weeping? That’s devastating right there.

It’s understandable that, being heartbroken, lonely, and heavily intoxicated, Lord John might have stumbled into Claire’s room that night. She had been brooding over her own mortality (Jamie’s memory keeping her from that fate), lamenting to the skies, and drowning her sorrows in whiskey. Their encounter on the bedroom floor is incredibly intimate (perhaps the most intense moment of this story, so we’ll leave the rest to your imagination, fade to black!) that it’s hard to bear witness to. Both are filled with anger towards each other (Claire’s “he does not belong to you to mourn!” is quite impactful!), anger towards Jamie, immersed in their despair, and on the verge of irreversible damage. In a drunken frenzy, they grapple with each other; it’s a blend of struggling and desperately holding on for dear life.

In the morning, finding themselves together, there’s a unique sense of closeness between them. Their confession that they each thought about Jamie during their intimacy signifies a profound level of trust, though they might not acknowledge it openly. It’s likely quite comforting for John to have someone he can openly discuss Manoke, the cook at his Virginia estate who shares an open relationship with him, even if his comparison of their relationship to a magical deer that comes and goes seems more like a Colonial Casanova’s attempt than a romantic or enchanting one. The scene suggests that, should it be necessary, these two could potentially live a harmonious life as married friends.

The scenario won’t be smooth sailing, naturally. The first hurdle arises when Claire and John visit Henry Grey, who’s convalescing at Mercy Woodcock’s residence. To everyone’s surprise, Henry announces his deep affection for Mercy and expresses their desire to get married. John, taken aback, seems bewildered, which immediately triggers a discussion between Claire and him. In the heated exchange, Claire accuses John of being bigoted due to his opposition to Henry marrying a Black woman. On their return journey, she voices her disapproval, pointing out that there are clandestine churches in Philadelphia that perform weddings for interracial couples. She also reminds John of the pain and heartache that comes with love being forbidden. John defends himself, stating his concerns about Mercy’s past and the potential dangers they might face if they were to marry without approval. He fears for their safety, as well as the consequences it would have on Henry’s relationship with his father. Despite his initial resistance, John seems deeply troubled by the idea of such a life for his nephew. The situation certainly sheds light on John’s character, and one might even argue that Claire is winning this argument – perhaps they should consider a spinoff for Henry and Mercy!

The disagreement Claire deems unimportant surfaces later when Lord John presents her with a dress and announces they’re hosting a grand fundraiser for local Loyalists. Naturally, Claire dislikes this; she remains a rebel until her last breath. One reason she refuses to travel back in time via the stones is because she and Jamie were committed to the fight for independence, and she wants to carry on that struggle in his memory. However, John explains they need to make their marriage appear genuine to quell suspicions about treasonous spy allegations (which it wasn’t). Essentially, he’s trying to protect Claire, but he needs her to cooperate slightly with the charade.

In the end, Claire dons a blue dress, adds Lord John’s wedding ring to her collection, and joins the festivities. This gathering offers two significant instances. Initially, Claire watches as William, who shares a special bond with Jamie, though he may not realize it, dismisses a woman named Peggy because, as he confesses to Claire, he is still heartbroken over Rachel. Claire offers her stepson advice, essentially suggesting that the best remedy for heartache is to find solace in someone else. It’s a sentiment I find endearing for both of them. Even if you were touched by Ian and Rachel’s promise of eternal love before they departed for Valley Forge, you can’t help but feel sorry for William who killed for Rachel only last week, and yet no one seems to be discussing it. It’s a tough break for him indeed.

Another key incident unfolds as an unexpected joy on the dance floor. Captain Richardson, you know, the same one who presented evidence to Lord John suggesting Claire was a spy, asks for a dance with her and reveals his allegiance to the rebels at the very moment. Quite frankly, he’s rather forthright about it. He proposes they collaborate, with Claire specifically gathering intel on and from Lord John’s brother, the Duke of Pardloe. While she supports the American cause, Claire has no intention of betraying Lord John; instead, she’ll act according to her own methods. She agrees to keep Richardson’s secret, but only to that extent.

It seems as though they’re gradually working together despite their varied perspectives, indicating an effort towards forming a partnership between Claire and Lord John.

Lo and behold, when things were finally looking up in my new marriage, who should barge through the door but Jamie Fraser – alive! His belongings managed to make it onto the ship, but Jamie himself? Nope! Now, I’m certain we’ll find out the reason later, but he requires Claire for their hasty escape since a horde of Redcoats are chasing him. Both Claire and Lord John are taken aback, but only one gets to share a tender moment with this resurrected heartthrob. The reunion is interrupted when John informs Jamie that their son is due soon, and he must leave posthaste. When Jamie asks, “William, is he here?” it’s clear as day that William was listening in on our conversation – if you didn’t catch the subtle implication, then perhaps you’re not too familiar with TV dramas.

Discovering that Jamie is indeed William’s true father turns out exactly as I had imagined. Contrary to the brief, dubious claim that Jamie had perished, this revelation is authentic, lasting, and heart-wrenching. The manner in which William shouts at both Jamie (now James) — a moment that William may not recall the historical “stinking papist” reference, please take note of the context — and then at John, will cast a shadow on your day. And if it doesn’t, consider revisiting earlier in the episode when John conveyed to William that his life holds value because of his son, and now there’s a chance he could lose him!!

Good gravy, Lord John is certainly receiving quite a beating in this episode! Let’s keep our fingers crossed that he can find an opportunity to meet with Manoke soon and continue their secret deer hunting partnership. I guess the episode concludes with Jamie aiming a gun at John’s head and apparently taking him captive, which causes the Redcoats to halt their invasion of the house. However, it seems likely that this situation will take up some of his time, but hopefully there’s more to come after that.

Read More

2024-12-07 06:54