Taylor Sheridan’s Shocking Western: The Most Unforgettable Scene of the 2010s

by

In 2017, Taylor Sheridan finished his three-part series exploring the modern American West. It began with Denis Villeneuve’s Sicario, a gritty look at the dark side of the drug war, and continued with Hell or High Water, which followed two brothers desperate to save their family farm. For the final film, Sheridan wrote and directed a story that brought attention to the often-overlooked issue of missing Native American women on reservations.

Wind River is a stark and unsettling modern Western film featuring Jeremy Renner and Elizabeth Olsen. They play a wildlife tracker and an FBI agent who team up to investigate the death of an 18-year-old Native American woman. Natalie Hanson, a member of the Northern Arapaho tribe, is found frozen on the Wind River Reservation in Wyoming. The investigation reveals she was brutally attacked before she succumbed to the harsh winter conditions. The film is a difficult but unflinching story, and one scene is particularly shocking and has been called one of the most disturbing of the decade.

Taylor Sheridan Wanted to Open People’s Eyes With Wind River

After Wind River came out, people started saying it was based on a true story. However, Taylor Sheridan clarified that it wasn’t inspired by a single case. He explained that the script came from hearing many similar stories of unsolved crimes happening on Native American reservations throughout the US.

After researching numerous cases of murdered, missing, and sexually assaulted women on Native American reservations – many of which struggle with poverty and drug problems – he noticed a widespread lack of public awareness about this crisis. He explained to NPR that this lack of attention was precisely why he decided to make the film.

As a film buff, I was really struck by why Taylor Sheridan chose the Wind River Reservation as the setting for his story. Apparently, research showed some incredibly tough realities there. The New York Times reported a crime rate seven times the national average, a shocking 80% unemployment rate, and a life expectancy of just 49 years. But what really got to me – and to Sheridan and his team – was something they couldn’t find in all the statistics. They kept digging, contacting everyone at the Department of Justice and other agencies, but one crucial number remained hidden.

It struck me powerfully how the film’s refusal to center a single missing woman actually proved its point. The final title card hit especially hard: it stated that while we track missing persons in every other group, there are no official statistics for Native American women. It was a devastating realization, and a perfect culmination of everything the film was saying.

Wind River Paints a Bleak Picture, But Never Demonizes the Inhabitants of the Res

While investigating Natalie’s death on the harsh Wind River reservation, local FBI agent Cory Lambert observes how his colleague, Jane Banner, begins to understand the difficult lives of the people who live there.

Although some individuals on the reservation are problematic, most residents are simply ordinary people struggling with poverty and feeling forgotten. Sheridan believed many Americans didn’t understand Native American culture and aimed to show through his film that people living on reservations are, in many ways, no different from those living in cities.

These individuals share the same aspirations as everyone else in the nation, but many have faced significant challenges due to difficult weather conditions, limited resources, and a lack of job opportunities in their areas.

The film deliberately avoids portraying the people on the reservation as villains, even when investigating the circumstances surrounding Natalie’s death. Her father mentions she had started seeing someone new before she died, but he didn’t know his identity. Later, Banner learns from Natalie’s brother, Chip, that the boyfriend was Matt Rayburn, a white man employed at a local oil drilling site. However, when Matt’s badly injured and frozen body is discovered, Lambert and Banner are left unsure how to interpret the events.

Everyone naturally suspected the older man, especially since he was new to town, but the real story might be more complex than it seems.

The core of Wind River relies on a shocking flashback that happens right when the suspense is at its highest. As Banner and tribal police chief Ben Shoyo investigate Rayburn’s colleagues at the oil drilling site, they learn he left days before after a heated fight with Natalie.

The atmosphere quickly becomes tense when someone reveals they know Natalie’s body has been discovered – information that hasn’t been made public. Immediately, the security guards pull their guns on Banner and Shoyo, leading to a dangerous and uncertain confrontation.

It All Leads to a Distressing Flashback Sequence That Burrowed Under the Audience’s Skin

The tension builds as the story flashes back to Natalie and Rayburn’s final night together. The scene starts sweetly, with the loving couple meeting in Rayburn’s trailer. While lying in bed, they discuss their future, and Rayburn expresses a desire to live a peaceful life in Ojai, California, rather than in bustling cities like New York or Chicago. This intimate and calm moment is shattered when Rayburn’s intoxicated colleagues stumble back from a night of drinking.

The group storms into Natalie’s trailer, immediately creating a tense and uncomfortable situation, with their leader, Pete, making several offensive remarks. Rayburn becomes increasingly frustrated, and when Pete attempts to look at Natalie under the blankets, Rayburn angrily kicks him, triggering a violent fight.

Sheridan portrays the terrible events with a detached, almost clinical approach, even as the conflict escalates to a brutal attack where oil workers kill a colleague and assault his girlfriend. The violence feels primal and hopeless, and the audience is left increasingly horrified as the man desperately fights against his attackers, ultimately succumbing to their overwhelming numbers.

Sheridan films the brutal attack on Natalie with unflinching directness, making it deeply disturbing to watch. By this point, the scene is intensely upsetting. The moment when Rayburn shouts for Natalie to escape, just before he’s overwhelmed by the attackers, is particularly heartbreaking. However, the audience understands that her desperate flight won’t lead to safety; the freezing weather will likely claim her life as soon as she leaves the trailer.

Sheridan doesn’t aim to simply shock us with this scene. He understands it’s painful to watch, and that it’s disturbing to realize how easily people can commit terrible acts. But his main goal is to make a powerful statement: Natalie wasn’t just a victim, another nameless woman lost in a cycle of violence. She was an individual whose life had value, and the injustice of what happened to her – and to countless others – deserves to be acknowledged and addressed.

Importantly, Natalie wasn’t killed by anyone from her community. Her death came at the hands of outsiders – people who came to the Reservation to exploit its resources, continuing a pattern that’s happened for generations.

Ultimately, Wind River aims to jolt viewers out of complacency, and while its ending is stark, it’s also powerfully meaningful.

Read More

2025-12-29 02:38