Manor Lords: Why Starting Weapons Should Be Shields, Spears, and Bows!

by

Manor Lords challenges you to not only construct your ideal medieval settlement, but also to defend it from frequent raids – often at the worst possible moments! A recent conversation on the game’s subreddit started when a player suggested a clever change to the game’s beginning: should villagers start with some basic weapons? The community overwhelmingly supports the idea of equipping villagers with spears, shields, and bows, allowing them to protect themselves without needing advanced crafting. This discussion about early-game defenses has clearly resonated with many players!

Shield, spear and maybe bow should be starting weapons
byu/trainedstork inManorLords

Summary

  • Trainedstork argues for a tiered system where villagers can start with basic weapons for better realism.
  • The sentiment across the comments leans positively, with many agreeing that starting with safety gear can enhance early game play.
  • A mixture of humor and agreement shines through in comments, with players supporting different weapon types to enrich gameplay.
  • Critics offer insights about realism and practicality of weapon choices, adding depth to the discussion.

The Case for Early Weaponry

Once you understand trainedstork’s argument, it seems obvious: why should villagers be helpless and wait for skilled craftspeople before they can protect themselves? Many players agree this isn’t just about how the game works, but about making sense in the game’s world. Trainedstork points out that basic tools like spears and shields shouldn’t be difficult to obtain, since people would naturally use whatever’s at hand. This idea is widely supported, with players suggesting that ordinary villagers should be able to quickly create simple defenses from common tools. One player jokingly asked, “Should they really have to wait for their farming tools before fighting off bandits?” It just doesn’t make sense to be defenseless simply because a blacksmith hasn’t arrived yet.

Balancing the Game

A key issue we’ve discussed is making the beginning of the game more balanced. The current design, where players start with no defense against bandits, can be really frustrating. One player jokingly pointed out how strange it is to give untrained villagers only a random assortment of spears to protect themselves. Many players feel helpless when bandits attack right away, especially while they’re trying to get a blacksmith built. The idea is that villagers should have some basic, improvised weapons from the start – something that reflects the realities of early medieval life without making the game too difficult. It doesn’t make sense to ask villagers to wait for better equipment while their homes are being raided!

User Responses and Humor

It’s great to see the community enjoying some laughs while discussing the game. One player cleverly acted out a funny scene: a child warning about bandits, and a father obsessing over paperwork instead of protecting them. This joke perfectly captured the frustration many players feel with the game’s early mechanics, which can make dealing with simple threats surprisingly difficult. Most players agree that starting weapons should be more useful and less restricted, allowing for quicker and more natural encounters with bandits. A little humor and relatable moments like these really enhance the gameplay experience without sacrificing the game’s overall realism.

Realism vs. Gameplay

Players are consistently asking for more realism in the game. One player pointed out that villagers wouldn’t realistically use makeshift spears, arguing that the game should focus on what helped people survive in medieval times, not just how it looked. This has sparked a debate about what weapons players should start with. While many want handcrafted spears, others suggest using actual farming tools – like axes, scythes, or hoes – as starting weapons. This idea adds an interesting angle to the discussion, considering both self-defense and historical accuracy, which could be a great addition to the game’s next update.

I’ve been seeing a lot of players, myself included, talk about giving villagers some basic weapons when you first start in Manor Lords. It’s not that we want to make the game easy, we just want things to feel a little more realistic and make those early hours more fun. Honestly, the community seems pretty united on this, so I’m hoping the developers will consider adding something like spears or bows. It’s cool to see a simple discussion about weapons turn into a bigger conversation about how the game works and bring everyone closer. Fingers crossed our villagers get the tools they need to defend against those bandit raids – one invasion at a time!

Read More

2025-12-01 09:59