Joel Edgerton’s Anti-Charisma Has Become His Greatest Strength

by

I’m absolutely blown away by Joel Edgerton’s performance in Train Dreams. Seriously, people are saying it’s the best work of his career, and I completely agree. Clint Bentley’s film is a really powerful, sad drama – honestly, it’s my pick for the best movie of the year so far. It’s the story of one man’s life, and the film stays completely focused on him, even though he’s often just…observing. Edgerton does so much with just his expressions that by the end, it feels like the actor and the character are one and the same. It’s strange, but it almost feels like his entire career before this movie just…disappeared, and all that’s left is this role.

It’s surprising to realize this actor has appeared in so many major films. He first gained recognition playing Uncle Owen in Star Wars: Attack of the Clones, and has since been in movies like King Arthur, Exodus: Gods and Kings (where his casting caused some debate), The Great Gatsby, and Smokin’ Aces. I always thought he was in Blackhawk Down, but it was actually Zero Dark Thirty. For a long time, it was hard to categorize him as an actor. Was he a leading man, a character actor, or a strong supporting player? He never quite became a traditional movie star, and didn’t seem interested in that level of fame, but he often played very similar roles. He consistently portrayed quiet, stoic characters – reliable when he was on the good side, and unyielding when he was the villain. He excelled in roles where his reserved nature contrasted with more outgoing co-stars. He’s a great match for Chiwetel Ejiofor in Kinky Boots, and in the now-classic film Warrior, he’s captivating as a quiet high school teacher competing in an MMA tournament against his troubled war veteran brother (played by Tom Hardy).

Joel Edgerton has always defied typical leading man expectations. Instead of commanding attention, he often plays subtle, almost forgettable characters. Early in his career, this led to unremarkable roles, but it’s become a defining strength. While always talented, it’s only recently that he’s developed the depth to truly embody complex, troubled characters – not just act as them. Before his recent work, one of his most notable achievements was writing, directing, and starring in the 2015 psychological thriller, The Gift. In it, he plays Gordo, a strange and largely overlooked figure from Jason Bateman’s high school past, who may be seeking revenge. The Gift cleverly utilizes Edgerton’s understated presence and enigmatic nature, leaving the audience constantly questioning his motivations. The film demonstrates that Edgerton understands how to best showcase his talents both as a director and an actor.

The following year, Joel Edgerton starred in Jeff Nichols’s Loving, portraying Richard Loving, a quiet and steadfast Virginia man whose marriage to Ruth Negga (in a standout performance) led to a pivotal 1967 Supreme Court decision. Edgerton’s character is unassuming and reserved, leading some prejudiced characters to underestimate him. Though a historical drama, the film feels strikingly immediate due to its simple and direct approach. Nichols focuses on the everyday lives of this ordinary couple, and Edgerton beautifully conveys a man who loves his wife deeply, yet is also burdened by the hardship his marriage causes her, making his performance both genuine and deeply affecting.

Joel Edgerton is incredibly prolific, continuing to write and direct films like the historical drama The King and Boy Erased alongside his acting work, suggesting a strong desire to focus on directing. Train Dreams feels like a perfect project for him, as he’s mentioned reading the original novella shortly after it was published in 2011 and immediately wanting to adapt it. However, it took years before he connected with the right director, Robert Bentley, and by then, he’d also become a father and was entering a new phase of his career. The story follows the life of Robert Grainier from childhood to old age, meaning the actor’s age wasn’t a major concern. In fact, it’s hard to imagine Edgerton taking on this role earlier in his career.

I’ve really noticed a change in Joel Edgerton’s performances as he’s matured. He’s become incredibly compelling to watch, and his face just shows so much – a real map of past mistakes and regrets. In Paul Schrader’s Master Gardener, he plays this former white supremacist assassin, now in witness protection, trying to live a normal, quiet life. But his past comes back to haunt him, and we see him wrestling with the violence that’s still inside. It’s funny, because he’s playing a relatively passive character – something you’re always told to avoid – but he’s absolutely captivating. It’s all in the small details of his performance; it’s just masterful.

A common challenge for actors today is showing a character’s inner thoughts on screen, especially when the script doesn’t explicitly state them. They often overact, appearing strange, or underact, seeming stiff and lifeless. The key is subtlety—never fully revealing what a character is thinking to maintain an air of mystery. We, as the audience, should only get a partial glimpse into their minds. This approach doesn’t always work well in big-budget blockbusters, which tend to be very direct, as seen in Joel Edgerton’s performance in Exodus. However, it’s crucial to the success of many great dramas. Edgerton demonstrated this skill in both Master Gardener and the Australian thriller The Stranger, where he played an undercover cop. In The Stranger, he deliberately obscured his expressions with a beard and shadowy lighting, making his character’s true intentions unclear. This ambiguity is compelling; the less we can read on his face, the more intrigued we become. While the film isn’t perfect, Edgerton’s performance is often the strongest element. He consistently employs this technique in his roles, and makes it appear completely natural.

I was captivated by Train Dreams when I first saw it at Sundance, and my appreciation for it has only grown since. I can’t forget Joel Edgerton’s heartbreaking performance, often shown in close-up. He plays a logger who doesn’t know—or care much about—his family history. He’s not well-educated, driven, or ambitious—not the typical hero of a story. What makes Train Dreams so special—with its storytelling feeling like an old tale and its broad scope—is how it elevates the life of an ordinary man to something mythic. This is also what makes it so impactful: this quiet, confused character feels more relatable than the dramatic heroes and heroines we usually see in movies. It takes an exceptionally talented and magnetic actor to pull it off, and Joel Edgerton delivers. He’s moved beyond being just a recognizable face to becoming a truly unforgettable performer.

Read More

2025-11-26 20:55