Detective thrillers have a familiar formula that audiences generally enjoy. They typically feature flawed, morally gray characters unraveling a complicated mystery, all set against a moody and visually striking backdrop. Viewers usually follow a tough, world-weary hero or heroine as they gather clues, hoping for a surprising and satisfying resolution.
Detective thrillers are a popular genre, but because audiences have seen so many, they’re familiar with common plot devices like mysterious women, misleading clues, and objects everyone is searching for. This often means viewers can guess the ending or feel like they know what’s coming. From classics like The Maltese Falcon to darker films like Seven, many stories follow a predictable path. However, some films successfully avoid these clichés, offering genuinely surprising and original narratives. These films might play with the story’s format, create unexpected motivations for characters, or even blend in humor. Ultimately, these unique detective stories still deliver exciting thrills, but in a fresh and unconventional way.
‘Memento’ (2000)
Newmarket Films
Christopher Nolan’s debut film, Memento, centers around a man trying to solve his wife’s murder. What makes this thriller stand out is its unique storytelling: the plot unfolds in reverse order. Unlike typical detective stories that reveal clues gradually, Memento challenges viewers to piece together the timeline and uncover the truth themselves, making the film’s structure a puzzle in itself.
The unique reverse storytelling of Memento is essential to its success. If the film unfolded chronologically, it would reveal its biggest surprise right away, spoiling the clever way the mystery unfolds. Even after multiple viewings, fans continue to discover new details, solidifying Memento as one of Christopher Nolan’s most brilliant and surprising films.
‘Butt Boy’ (2019)
Epic Pictures
The film Butt Boy is a wildly unpredictable thriller, pushing the boundaries of believability. It centers on a detective who suspects his AA sponsor is involved in the disappearance of a child. The bizarre twist? The detective believes his sponsor is smuggling people… through his rectum. As it turns out, the suspect possesses a strange, almost magical ability to make things – and people – vanish, and this is all happening in a real, actual movie!
The film offers a fresh and unusual concept, and its humor and scares come from how earnestly it presents this bizarre story. As the investigation unfolds, it delves into surprisingly dark territory, culminating in a third act that’s unlike anything audiences have ever seen – and perfectly fits the film’s overall tone.
‘Brick’ (2005)
Focus Features
Before directing the popular Knives Out movies, Rian Johnson created a truly original detective film called Brick. It took the classic, tough detective style and reimagined it within a high school, starring Joseph Gordon-Levitt as a student investigating a murder. The film stood out because of its unusual setting and the way characters spoke—the fast-paced, hard-boiled dialogue felt surprisingly out of place in a high school, constantly challenging the viewer to follow along.
The investigation into a murder quickly reveals hidden agendas and a disturbing group within the student body. Though it feels unique and unconventional, Brick still captures the essence of a detective story, offering a consistently surprising and thrilling experience. The excellent writing and strong acting are major strengths as well.
‘The Wicker Man’ (1973)
British Lion Films/Warner Bros.
The film The Wicker Man starts as a seemingly straightforward search for a missing girl, taking place on a secluded island. Though the 2006 remake with Nicolas Cage is known for being bad, the original movie creates a genuinely unsettling atmosphere that keeps viewers on edge. The ending isn’t a typical resolution to a mystery; while there are answers to the central question, the film has a surprising twist that often leaves audiences shocked.
Though The Wicker Man starts like a detective story, it quickly breaks the mold. The mystery of the missing person isn’t the point; the film is more interested in hinting at something much larger and unsettling, creating a dark and surprisingly unpredictable experience.
‘Paige Darcy: Reluctant Detective’ (2025)
InFuse Releasing/Multivisionnaire Pictures
“Paige Darcy: Reluctant Detective” is a new book that cleverly uses familiar mystery story elements for laughs. The main character is a detective, similar to Nancy Drew, who’s grown tired of solving crimes. She decides she’s done with cases—until a seemingly simple missing cat investigation pulls her into a surprisingly dark and violent mystery that’s also full of humor.
Paige Darcy takes on cases that are truly dangerous, and she playfully subverts typical mystery tropes. Expect action, backstabbing, and unexpected turns as this once-underestimated millennial detective matures and moves beyond her early, amateur style.
‘Unknown Origins’ (2020)
Netflix
Unknown Origins blends the feel of a gritty murder mystery like Seven with the classic elements of a superhero origin story. What makes it unique is that the killer stages each murder to look like a scene from a comic book’s beginnings, all while searching for someone he sees as his heroic match.
“Unknown Origins” is a solid detective story with a captivating plot that blends different genres, keeping it interesting. Both superhero enthusiasts and mystery lovers will find something to enjoy in this film, which cleverly twists expectations with a dark and sometimes violent storyline. Just as Matt Reeves’ “The Batman” feels more like a gritty crime thriller than a typical superhero movie, “Unknown Origins” does the same, but with a completely new concept.
‘I Saw the Devil’ (2010)
Magnolia Pictures
The thriller I Saw the Devil starts with a classic premise: a detective hunting a serial killer. However, the story takes a dark turn when it’s revealed the killer murdered the detective’s fiancée. Driven by grief and a thirst for revenge, the detective doesn’t just try to arrest the killer – he captures and repeatedly releases him, subjecting him to a cycle of psychological torment.
The film I Saw the Devil centers around a relentless pursuit where the question isn’t who is the hunter, but how far the detective will go to get revenge. Unlike typical thrillers that play with shades of gray, the protagonist consistently commits terrible acts. Though the killer is equally monstrous and offers his own justifications, the movie pushes boundaries and explores darker territory than most films in the genre.
‘Mystery Team’ (2009)
Roadside Attractions
While Mystery Team leans more into comedy than genuine thrills, it’s the blend of both that really makes the movie work. It centers around a group of grown-up detectives who usually handle silly, unimportant cases. But their newest investigation is different – it’s genuinely dangerous, and the movie cleverly uses these high stakes for comedic effect.
MovieWeb Report: Subscribe and never miss what matters
Immerse yourself in the cinematic universe with the latest movie news, reviews, and exclusive content from MovieWeb.
Donald Glover and Aubrey Plaza shine in the quirky detective film Mystery Team, which cleverly flips the usual tropes by focusing on inexperienced characters caught up in dangerous situations. It balances over-the-top humor with a genuinely intriguing mystery, making it a unique detective story. However, its unconventional style might not appeal to all viewers.
‘The Empty Man’ (2020)
20th Century Fox
The Empty Man is a creepy and suspenseful detective story with horror elements. It follows a former police officer as he investigates a series of disappearances linked to a frightening local myth. What starts as a simple search for a missing child quickly spirals into a disturbing mystery involving secret groups, supernatural beliefs, and a shocking twist you won’t see coming.
I was completely captivated by The Empty Man, and what really struck me was its daring structure. The movie starts with a nearly 20-minute opening sequence before we even meet the main characters! It’s a bold move, but it totally works, drawing you in for the full two-plus hour ride. And the ending? Wow. The final reveal was a shocking twist I absolutely didn’t see coming, especially considering it started as what seemed like a pretty standard detective story.
‘Who Framed Roger Rabbit’ (1988)
Buena Vista Pictures Distribution
Many people see Who Framed Roger Rabbit as a fun cartoon movie for kids. But beneath its playful mix of live-action and animation, it’s actually a clever and unconventional detective comedy that breaks the mold of its genre.
Who Framed Roger Rabbit is a detective story with a hard-boiled, classic noir feel. It follows a world-weary investigator as he solves a murder involving the captivating Jessica Rabbit. The film doesn’t shy away from darker themes, showing toons being harmed and featuring a villain who frightened many viewers as children. Beyond its impressive visuals, Who Framed Roger Rabbit is a truly great detective movie that consistently surprises audiences and defies typical genre conventions.
Found an error? Send it info@movieweb.com so it can be corrected.
Read More
- Lacari banned on Twitch & Kick after accidentally showing explicit files on notepad
- Adolescence’s Co-Creator Is Making A Lord Of The Flies Show. Everything We Know About The Book-To-Screen Adaptation
- The Batman 2 Villain Update Backs Up DC Movie Rumor
- YouTuber streams himself 24/7 in total isolation for an entire year
- These are the last weeks to watch Crunchyroll for free. The platform is ending its ad-supported streaming service
- What time is It: Welcome to Derry Episode 8 out?
- Elizabeth Olsen’s Love & Death: A True-Crime Hit On Netflix
- Amanda Seyfried “Not F***ing Apologizing” for Charlie Kirk Comments
- Jane Austen Would Say: Bitcoin’s Turmoil-A Tale of HODL and Hysteria
- Southern Charm Recap: The Wrong Stuff
2026-02-03 16:23