10 Creepy Hidden Gems To Stream On Disney+

I’m a big Disney+ fan, and you might be surprised to learn it’s actually a great place to find spooky movies for Halloween! It launched back in 2019 as a way to watch all of Disney’s classics and new shows. Now, it’s grown to include content from all of Disney’s different companies too, so there’s a ton to choose from.

As a film buff, I’ve been really surprised by Disney+ lately. Sure, it’s always had those classic, slightly spooky Disney movies, but now it’s packed with genuinely scary horror and thriller films from all sorts of studios. Adding those other catalogs has really changed things – it’s not just for families anymore. Honestly, that’s great news because it means there are a ton of hidden gems and underrated movies just waiting to be discovered on the platform.

Halloween is the perfect time for scary movies, but after watching the same classics over and over, they don’t feel as frightening anymore. Luckily, Disney+ has a lot of hidden horror gems – many are actually scarier than the popular favorites! Whether you’re looking for something the whole family can enjoy or a truly terrifying experience, Disney+ has you covered this spooky season.

Piggy (2022)

The 2022 Spanish film, Piggy, blends thriller and horror elements with some genuinely unsettling scenes. It centers on a bullied teenager who feels conflicted when those who tormented her are taken hostage. While the movie explores important themes, it successfully balances those ideas with the demands of the thriller and horror genres, never sacrificing suspense or scares.

Piggy unfolds a little slower than most horror movies, but the ending makes it worthwhile. It’s quite different from typical Halloween horror, which usually focuses on monsters and supernatural events, and encourages viewers to think deeper about the story. While Piggy might not appeal to all audiences, it’s a great choice for horror fans who are looking for something more substantial.

The Clovehitch Killer (2018)

Drawing inspiration from the crimes of the BTK Killer, The Clovehitch Killer is a well-made horror film in the style of true crime stories. It follows a teenager who begins to suspect his father is a famous serial killer, offering a unique take on the typical coming-of-age story. While it doesn’t rely on jump scares, the film builds tension incredibly well.

It’s rare for a modern film to create the same unsettling atmosphere as The Clovehitch Killer, and it’s really difficult to build that kind of suspense. The movie’s focus on family makes it even scarier, but also surprisingly sad. The Clovehitch Killer is a great find, a hidden gem that any movie lover will enjoy.

When Evil Lurks (2023)

Demonic possession is a common theme in horror, but When Evil Lurks feels fresh and terrifying. The story follows a farmer who has to escape his home after a neighbor becomes possessed. Unlike most possession movies, this one avoids tired tropes and delivers a truly unsettling, disturbing, and exciting experience.

The film features disturbingly realistic, decaying corpses, leaning into a gruesome style of horror. What truly sets it apart is its willingness to fully commit to its dark concepts, pushing boundaries that many other horror films avoid. Though not entirely polished, When Evil Lurks is a remarkably intense and unforgettable cinematic experience.

Presence (2024)

Steven Soderbergh’s horror film, Presence, has sparked a lot of debate among horror fans, largely because it does things differently than most movies in the genre. The film is unusual in that it’s shot from the point of view of a strange being that’s haunting a house and observing the family who just moved in. While modern ghost stories have evolved, Presence stands out as truly original.

As a horror fan, I’d say this isn’t a movie that relies on jump scares. Instead, it creates a really unsettling atmosphere that’s hard to put your finger on. If you’re expecting a non-stop, action-packed fright fest, you might be let down. But honestly, Presence is really satisfying in a different way. What I loved is that it proves horror can still be fresh and original, and it’s amazing to see a lower-budget film be so creative and push the genre forward.

Werewolves Within (2021)

Werewolves Within is considered the best video game movie adaptation so far, and it’s a genuinely enjoyable horror comedy. The film, inspired by the game of the same name, follows the people of a small town who find themselves stuck together during a blizzard, as a strange monster begins to terrorize them. It’s a lighthearted and silly movie that offers both laughs and scares.

Despite its small budget, Werewolves Within is a surprisingly good movie thanks to its talented cast who perfectly capture the film’s unique atmosphere. While not strictly a horror film, it’s reminiscent of the fun, classic horror-comedies from earlier eras – a type of movie we don’t see much anymore. Originally released in 2021, it’s recently gained popularity on streaming services.

In A Violent Nature (2024)

With so many different kinds of horror movies out there, a classic slasher like In A Violent Nature feels like a breath of fresh air. The story centers around a group of teenagers who unintentionally bring a vengeful killer back to life, and he starts attacking anyone in his search for a missing locket. What makes this movie unique is the perspective – instead of following the victims, you mostly see things through the killer’s eyes.

While In A Violent Nature fits the slasher genre, it also cleverly subverts common horror tropes with its humor. The film’s effective use of gore, combined with a deliberate slow burn, creates a strangely dreamlike and suspenseful mood. This Canadian film isn’t simply a throwback to classic slashers; it offers a fresh take on the formula.

Crimes Of The Future (2022)

With his 2022 film Crimes of the Future, director David Cronenberg reaffirmed his status as the king of body horror. The film features a provocative performance artist whose shocking acts examine what could be the next step in human evolution. It’s a deeply unsettling and bizarre movie, representing body horror at its most intense.

The movie excels at creating a strange and unsettling world, portraying a future that feels truly alien. The horror stems from how detached and inhuman the characters are, and the film offers one of the most bleak and disheartening visions of the future ever put on screen. While it’s not a fast-paced thriller, Crimes of the Future is a film that stays with you long after the credits roll.

Late Night With The Devil (2023)

While found footage films were popular about ten years ago, Late Night with the Devil revitalizes the genre with a unique approach. The movie is presented almost entirely as recordings from a late-night talk show that unexpectedly encounters something truly evil. David Dastmalchian delivers a fantastic performance, and the talk show format cleverly enhances the frightening moments.

One of the best things about Late Night with the Devil is how straightforward it is – it doesn’t try to be more than it needs to be. The movie also tells a genuinely interesting story that unfolds subtly while the spooky events happen. Though it didn’t get a lot of attention in theaters, it’s a hidden gem worth checking out on streaming, especially around Halloween.

Return To Oz (1985)

Released 45 years after the original The Wizard of Oz (1939), Return to Oz aimed to recreate the magic of the first film. The story finds Dorothy back in Oz, but this time it’s ruled by a wicked empire. While the movie features impressive special effects and puppetry, it has a surprisingly unsettling and even frightening tone.

Despite being a Disney movie, Return to Oz contains genuinely frightening scenes that are comparable to those in horror films. This unique quality made it a hidden gem, setting it apart from other Disney titles, and it’s now a beloved cult classic. While not strictly a horror movie, it’s still capable of giving viewers a scare.

Something Wicked This Way Comes (1983)

Buena Vista/courtesy Everett Collection

Disney+ is now streaming Something Wicked This Way Comes for the very first time, making the beloved, but often overlooked, movie available to a wider audience. The film, adapted from a Ray Bradbury novel, tells the story of two boys whose peaceful lives are disrupted by the arrival of a mysterious and unsettling carnival. It quickly became clear that this Disney movie wasn’t intended for young children, as it delves into darker, more mature themes.

With its classic autumn atmosphere and subtly creepy feeling, Something Wicked This Way Comes creates a sense of unease. While not overly frightening, it’s surprisingly scary for a movie made for kids. Now that it’s available to stream on Disney+, this overlooked gem is finally getting the attention it deserves.

2025-10-21 23:01